Jump to content

elaine_roberts1

Members
  • Posts

    835
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by elaine_roberts1

    Untitled

          5
    Appropriately for the season, this actually reminds me of a Menorah with a few extra branches. Very eye catching. Can't decide if a little more contrast would make it "snap" more....

    Trang Chieu

          8
    Very interesting shot. The composition is faboulous and the colors bright (was there a filter involved?. I love the soft white moon as a counter point to the sharp, almost-silhouette of the man and his nets.

    Untitled

          130
    Whatever manipulation to the tones has or hasn't been done by the photographer, it hasn't altered the fundamentals of the image, and I think the effect is very painterly. I think that this type of photography links back to the discipline of oil painting and other "arts of inclusion" joining together the image captured by the film/sensor and the image envisoned by the artist. Beautiful work.

    Brooklodge

          12
    I think it's a great shot as-is; I'm not a fan of the vingnette. The light and background is beautiful. Perhaps burn in the corners just a little to focus attention, but nothing so extreme as the vingette posted.

    Wagon Wheel...

          7

    I like the flare - I think its adds interest and energy to the scene. Blocking it out, the photo is pretty but kind of boring. The sun add that little extra something. The only critique I have is that the colors seem a bit green-shifted. But I love the sense of cold quiet in the snow (I miss Minnesota, this reminds me of it).

    4341887.jpg

    breakfast in Tia

          67
    I can feel the chill and the hot tea in my hand. An incredible moment you've caught here - not only the light, but the positions of the people, the look over the shoulder. 7/6 (which I don't give lightly).

    Beijing Smoker

          5

    This is a great moment that captures the everyday activities that are universal - but with unique cultural details.

     

    I think that this image could use some minor touch ups. A square crop would put more emphasis on the man's face (rather than back) and some adjustments to levels, color balance, sharpening, plus some dodge/burn to darken the background a little, would show this image off to the best effect. What do you think?

    3778835.jpg

    portrait

          20
    I think that the background adds a lot to this shot. Its texture and age matches that of the subject's face, and the color contrasts with the red of her clothing. A great catch.

    Wheat

          5
    I love the dramatic lighting and wild background. Was this a set or location? The horizon seems to be slightly tilted to the right.
  1. I like the warm light and tones, but she seems trapped in that tight crop. Was this the full frame, or did you cut some off? I'd especially like to see some more space above her head and off to the left (where she's looking).
×
×
  • Create New...