Jump to content

rjacksonphoto

PhotoNet Pro
  • Posts

    1,606
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by rjacksonphoto

    Ghetto Fabulous

          11
    Well-seen and nicely composed. The high contrast blows out the highlights a little in the upper left-hand corner of the building but that isn't a problem because high-contrast helps pop the window colors. Lowering the contrast might be more realistic, but that would be a different photo. Good shot.

    Untitled

          2

    I think this one is great! Excellent composition, especially considering you weren't looking through the viewfinder.

     

    It's a little blurry. Maybe a tripod... just kidding! Nice shot.

  1. I like the Holga effect.

     

    You've certainly captured an obese person walking in the direction of food. I'm just not sure what the statement is here. That a lot of people are obese? That obese people eat?

     

    If you were able to give us some photographic insight into this woman's life and her struggle with her crippling weight, then I would consider this an excellent photograph. Did you, by any chance, talk to her?

  2. Hmmmm...certainly has nice colors. And the composition is good. I'm not sure why the background is blue and the foreground is red. The kayak/kayaker looks a little dark on my monitor. I'm not sure of the purpose of the underwater structure in the composition. The wake of the boat looks a little funny-- dare I say-- unnatural? Curious...

    Untitled

          150

    Felix

     

    I see your point, but, for me, the image looked funny from the start. The blurs didn't seem to make any sense on first viewing, which made it difficult to suspend my disbelief. And, in a fantasy image like this, you have to be able to suspend your disbelief. As someone pointed out in the thread on the POW I referenced above, it is like seeing the boom mike in a movie. Suddenly, you're no longer on a South Sea island, but on the backlot at MGM.

     

    I really like the composition (I tend to compose like this myself) and I think this is what a lot of people react to here on a gut level. It's just that it is too easy to see the man behind the curtain (another movie reference)...

    Untitled

          150

    I agree with those who say the idea is good but the image fails in execution. I can't see any reason for the blurred horizon other than to hide the cut and paste of the sky. Reminds me of the POW a few months back with all of the cloned boats-- once the PS work becomes apparent, everything falls apart. I guess the moral is if you're going to use PS for major manipulation, you'd better be good at it.

     

    I'm disappointed in all of the gushing as well and glad I'm not alone in thinking that this work is a little slipshod.

    .

          4
    A little contrasty on my monitor but a good shot, nonetheless. Are they brothers? I like the fact that they seem quite serious.
×
×
  • Create New...