asher_lev

I do not care for the "nothingness" on the left side. However I like a lot of your other work.

Not exciting. Has no message. If this is one of your all time best than what can be said about your other photographs? Also how could all that red be in the real scene?? I mean why the photo shop for that? Does the photograph look better worse as it really was. Just some comments and thoughts

Somewhere you said; what is the point of a "??". The point is: "what is the point of the photo. "??" is an improvement over a low rating given without explanation (which is almost always). To your defense  "what is the point?" can be said about most any "street" photo. What  sets you a bit apart is that sometimes you pick a scene and wait for a matching moment. A good photo hits you in the face. I've not seen that over here. The girl, by the way is way oversharpend and the "fake" halo...I don't know exactly what to say. Good "Depth of Field".

It is past time to grow up John Crosely.

5 nice photo. colors composition variety of the bikines and focus

??

congrats. I could find only 1 photo on the link though

This was posted once before. The exact same image as I recall.

In which case the title and text are necessary to understand the photo.

I see a man on a cell phone.

really nice

6/7

I like this. Good sharp focus DOF and expression is real.  5/7

I agree with Samrat. Judging from the halo effect it is over sharpened

Marta; I really like your work but I don't think so on this one. Just too harsh for me although what you intended. But it has an original effect.

good lighting and body form. I think bw is much better.

a greenish yellow color on her right bicept. I think you should take it out.

thank you

I absolutely do not like "street' so it is nice to see something else. Great portrait.

??

I like all of the tones except the while towel. It distracts me and is blow out is one place. tough to control whites. good photo I think and so do others

nice smile

the out of focus girl on the left does not help the photo

I don't get this photo at all.

when i see this I think of pnina