arnabbanerjee

December 3, 2004

Yeye,

When I submit a photo for critique, I am looking for comments to improve my technique and other aspects of the photography. If you just leave a low rating but do not mention why you did not like the photo, then it does not add any value to this wonderful community - please mention your points - even if your english is weak, everyone will understand. Thanks for visiting my photos

December 2, 2004

Tom,

I think that the moon is over-exposed - no details there - just a white blob. Also other than the leaves, the rest of the image is not drawing attention. May be including more of the leaves by moving camera to the right is an option. Sky is also blank and not intersting. But all these are constructive comments - I think that your approach was very good and the blue color tone creates a nice mood - but overall quality and composition can be improved more.

December 2, 2004

Rajeev, As always you did a great job in capturing the natural mood. I like the composition and your placement of camera - not too crazy about the light - but I guess that was not in your hand. Thanks for sharing your great works

December 2, 2004

I like the picture - not too great - but like it. But the discussion here was dramatic - good to see so many passionate people here - keep it up guys

December 1, 2004

Ratings are appreciated, but comments are even better - please

comment on any aspect..thanks

November 30, 2004

Colors are little oversaturated here - also boundaries of glass are disappearing in the background. You may have done it on purpose - but the image may have another option with well defined borders - just an idea. Creative good work - 5/6

November 30, 2004

If this is a real life situation - kudos to you. As a photograph, it will be improved if the grasses do not cover the tiger's face and the tiger looks up - but dont get eaten by trying to do so...

November 30, 2004

please critique

November 29, 2004

Lack on interesrting subjects here - may be the bridge or whatever it is, a better object with the moon in the background.

November 29, 2004

Not very original but nice capture. I would try to place the bird on left bottom so that it is looking towards empty space in the front and beyond - just an idea

November 17, 2004

Color abstract

November 16, 2004

Don't get it - but weak composition as the right side yellow wall is a distraction. Have you tried BW version?

November 16, 2004

A difficult shot with extremes - white and black cups - but you managed well. The bottom right is a problem, but can be fixed using PS. Also, direct reflections are disturbing - without them, the picture may be more pleasing

November 16, 2004

The bottom dark part is somewhat not interesting - but lighting is very good

November 11, 2004

Comments and feedback please...

November 6, 2004

Too little DOF for my taste - but still a very original capture

November 5, 2004

Critique please..

October 29, 2004

Rajesh, You have captured a good moment, but I do not like this fill-in flash light here. It destroys all the shadows and makes this image rather flat. Try without flash (if possible) - I know that may be difficult, but that's how great photos are made