Jump to content

ecarter

Members
  • Posts

    598
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by ecarter

    self portrait

          2
    Interesting concept! I must say, if nothing else, this image does grab the attention of the viewer and is a challenge. I might have been tempted to use the more stereotypical "black bar censorship" rather than a round PS brush, but I like the idea. Of course, it's the hand covering the face with the sign that really grabs a hold, and the eyes behind the fingers.

    Mr Wu

          66
    This would be a wonderful portrait but the smoke manipulation ruins it for me, sorry. A great idea and portrait marred by poorly executed PS manipulation.

    My Aunt Loves Me

          3
    This is a wonderful portrait - from what I'm seeing, portraiture work like this is where you really shine out. There's a real feeling of connection - not just between the two subjects but also with the viewer/photographer. B/W is a good choice for this portrait as well. Nicely done.

    Insularity

          87
    I think this is a good photo that conveys both a feeling of vulnerability and furtiveness. I personally think that this would be stronger in b/w myself, but it holds up either way. The lighting and composition are fine as far as pose but something both my SO and I thought when looking at this photo is that the placement of the left hand is a little distracting - it might have been better to drop it behind the model in shadow so you only see the right hand on the door.

    redleaf

          6
    This is a good idea, but appears too soft (was there photoshopping watercolor effect on this?) and because of the soft appearance, doesn't work for me.

    "The Colonel"

          2
    It's a good montage of images, but for some reason this doesn't work for me - the portrait would have more impact closer on the face and the "props" and flag overlay are distracting to me rather than adding anything.

    zen-01

          4
    You've caught the essence of a zen garden here. Simple, clean and abstract - but the shadow makes it special for me. It reminds me of the shadow of a man praying. I don't know if that was the intent, but in any case well done.

    ***

          6
    The reflection here is colorful and interesting, the more so for having a ripple running through it - that really makes this photo stand out from other "reflection" shots I've seen.
  1. ...of an interesing scene. The weathered fence draws me neatly into the image and keeps my eye travelling back and forth across the scene.

     

    Regarding the sky, I do not think it is blown - I'm seeing tonality in the clouds pretty much all the way through, though there's a little harsh contrast with the landscape itself.

     

    Regarding composition, the only change I might have made would be to pull back a little further so the nearest "cross" in the fence isn't "cut" at the bottom and sides. Regarding the horizon, the fact that it doesn't sit on a "thirds" line here doesn't bother me - it lends balance as there is interesting detail both on the ground and in the sky here. After all, rules are there so you think before you break them. :-)

    Hot Horizon

          3
    What's the foreground object on the left hand edge of this shot? That draws my attenton from what would otherwise be a very arresting photograph. A few steps to the right would have been better I think.

    Tranquility

          2
    This looks like a very nice place, but the straight-on angle and the tree cut off on the side (and the trees along the bottom cut off) are distracting. Reshooting this location from a different perspective would probably work better.
  2. This could be a tad sharper, per your own comment, but I think you've caught this very well. The texture of the carpet anemone is very interesting and tends to hold my attention. Although it would have slowed your shutter even more, I think this could have been helped by greater DOF...

    Untitled

          11
    I can practically reach out and touch the grass, and smell the storm in the air. Nice perspective on the ruined boat as well, it helps pull me into this image and keep me there.
  3. Took this photo at the PA Ren Fest this year - decided it would look

    good as an "old fashioned" style photograph. I may post the

    unmanipulated version later, but wanted to run this one out first.

×
×
  • Create New...