<p>In April of 2012, Elinchrom announced the availability of new third-party speedrings to fit their highly regarded line of Rotalux modifiers to owners of non-Elinchrom gear. In November of the same year, Profoto announced their new RFi line of softboxes, along with their new line of third-party speedrings as well. Incredibly good news for owners of other brands of flash heads who've for years may have wanted either Elinchrom or Profoto modifiers for their other-branded flash heads. Since I now have a choice of two of the best-branded modifiers on the market, I thought I'd make a quick comparison. Here's my quick take on Elinchrom vs. Profoto.</p>
<p>Elinchrom Rotalux:<br /> + Excellent "umbrella-like" design for super-fast set-up and tear-down.<br /> + Unique flat-storage bag enables storing an un-tensioned modifier without disassembly.<br /> + Easy-in, 90-degree turning speedring receiver.<br /> + Availability of renowned Deep Octas to owners of non-Elinchrom strobes.<br /> + Deep-recessed diffusers for greater feathering ability.<br /> - Fabric eggcrates [softgrids] available only from Lighttools--large grids are very expensive (e.g., grid for 69" octa is $659).<br /> - Extra-large strips, squares, rectangles, and octas are very expensive ($967-$1,038).</p>
<p>Profoto RFi:<br /> + Price-competitive with third-party brands.<br /> + Available line of softgrids for each RFi product--most, reasonably priced.<br /> + Available line of masks.<br /> + Wide selection of rectangular, square, octa, and strip light boxes.<br /> + Color-coded pins.<br /> - Few improvements over previous versions.<br /> - No innovative umbrella, or quick-release design allowing for easier set-up.<br /> - Color-coded pins not a huge "feature."</p>
<p>For location use, I think the Elinchrom products are the clear winner. The innovative umbrella design and un-tensioned storage bags make set-up and break-down faster than any of their comptitors' products (save for the similar-folding, Paul C. Buff modifiers). However, for those wanting fabric eggcrates for each of their softboxes, Profoto makes one for each RFi product, many of which are reasonably priced.</p>