<p>Stefanie, thanks for the samples. A few observations,<br>
- The 15-85 clearly has much more chromatic abberation than the 17-50, this is causing the red/blue color fringes visible in those photos. It's remarkable how much better the 17-50 is in this regard.<br>
- Your shutter speed was high enough on all of these, camera shake is not likely to be a problem. <br>
- The 15-85 does seem a little weak, though it isn't awful. Since foregrounds seem to be better, I'm wondering if it's focusing too close, and if the small apertures you're using are concealing most of the focus error.<br>
Most lens problems will be easier to see with the lens wide open, so the small apertures are working against us for detecting problems, particularly focus errors.</p>