Jump to content

bdpics

Members
  • Posts

    279
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by bdpics

    Floating Leaf

          9
    Elegent, simple, clean. I'd like to see a version with some more sharpening on the distant part of the leaf. I love the tonality of this image and the feelings it instills.

    fence #2

          25
    As usual, wonderful black and white work! The only slight criticism I would offer is that to the right of the last piece of wood the tonality of the sky does not match the rest of the image.....
  1. This is a nice image, however to me it highlights why I dislike composite/manipulated images so much--it's deceitful.

     

    It leads us to believe that you witnessed this beautiful scene--maybe even visiting several times to get an idea of how sun and shadow moved across the scene, or even camping out there until the conditions were just right (as myself and many other landscape photographers have done) and then captured it at just the right moment--but that's not the case here.

     

    To me it's like comparing images of Eagles that were taken in the wild to images taken of caged Eagles. They may appear equal aesthetically, but there is really no comparison when you factor in the degree of difficulty.

     

    Don't get me wrong Kevin, I'm not picking on you personally, and I do note that you checked the box indicating that it might be manipulated. It's a pleasing image, but very much devalued in my mind because it's not real--kind of like the prom date with tissue in her bra......lol.

    Aaagh II

          5
    Wonderful portrait! I see some very small black flecks on her face--not sure if that's dust or natural blemishes. I'd be curious to see a version of this with the right side cropped very close to her ear--to me the out-of-focus locks of hair detract rather than add to the image.
×
×
  • Create New...