Jump to content

frenchie

Members
  • Posts

    15
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by frenchie

    The Beach Comber

          39

    An excellent shot technically and also in terms of interest - very amusing (he looks really cheesed off!)

     

    Great composition too with the sea/beach junction at 2/3rds and all that walking space to the right.

  1. Interesting, Thomas. Just as a matter of interest, what does it look like with no colour manipulation of the hand? I ask this because the PC screen background is sufficiently different from the jet-black background of the main pic so as to tell us it is a computer screen image we are looking at and not just a 'hand behind a frame'

     

    Just my 2c. I haven't rated your pic because I don't give ratings on other people's photos (a) I don't feel qualified to do so and (b) I think, in any case, IMHO the ratings should really cover three areas - aesthetics, originality, AND execution (or "technical merit"). But, just for the record, for me, with some changes to that hand, this would would score well in all three

    Leopard with kill

          10
    Yep, I agree wholheartedly about the cropping; as I said, I think the composition is just about perfect. The leopard occupies the top two-thirds of the frame and, without the meat, the viewer would be left wondering just what it was had engaged the leopard's interest

    Leopard with kill

          10

    I think the composition is perfect. A stunning shot. Was this in the wild?

     

    I haven't rated your pic because I don't give ratings on other people's photos (a) I don't feel qualified to do so and (b) I think, in any case, IMHO the ratings should really cover three areas - aesthetics, originality, AND execution (or "technical merit"). But, just for the record, for me, if it was taken in the wild this pic would score top marks in all three!

    Panoz

          5
    I like this picture; it's a cut above the run-of-the-mill motorsport shots. That's not to down-play other motorsport pics in this section, many of which are technically excellent, BUT they're the sort of thing you see in motorsport magazines every day. I just thought this picture was refreshingly different; it would make a good poster. I'm no expert; this is just a personal opinion

    two angels

          6
    IMHO a potentially good photo has been spoiled by it being out of focus (or as I'm a newbie here, maybe there's something wrong with the way I'm viewing it?)
×
×
  • Create New...