Jump to content

stefan1

Members
  • Posts

    385
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by stefan1

    Ras Nungwi Beach

          103

    To say that this is a snapshot just sounds snobbish to me, at least if the term isn't defined in some way... To me, a snapshot is a casually taken photograph without any particular preparation and I don't think that is necessarily the case here. As far as we know the photographer may have been waiting here for quite a while to get this constellation.

     

    There is no fancy lighting or edits here but the quality of the light in the photo captures the intensity I would imagine this scene would have. The colors and the sparse composition leaves me with a delicious light feeling, perfect for daydreaming as somebody else noted above...

    "Narcissa"

          131
    Hello David - while the subject of this does not excite me terribly, I think this image has gorgeous light and I enjoy the opportunity to learn a little from all the comments (pro and con). Your attitude (or lack thereof maybe :-) in replying to the commentary is commendable. Cheers, -Stefan.

    white on white

          142
    It seems to me that Doug's complaint about blown highlight is partially countered by his own version which shows that even in this very high-key image, there is quite a bit of detail to work with. Certainly there are some areas at 0xFF but the balance that was struck to achieve the extreme "white-on-white" look is very good in my book. I submit that with the limitations of 8-bits per channel, this is about as well one can do to achieve fili's idea here. The less extreme version simply represents a different set of visual ideals.

    Untitled

          85
    I think it is a wonderful shot and I have no doubts that the original print is a true gem. The sidetracking discussion of the probable causes of the "grain" (jpeg artefacts in my opinion) is a good illustration of what this technical imperfection does for the appreciation of the photo. It is very difficult to overcome the initial negative impression and as a result the photo fails to realize its potential.

    Tatty Daisy

          6
    I think this is a misunderstood flower... I find it very refreshing after all those picture perfect creations. The colors are powerful without feeling oversaturated, and there is a darkness to the photo that harmonized perfectly with the subject.

    Bathtime

          4

    Hi Mark - thanks for your comments and suggestions. I tend to avoid the red channel when I do digital b/w conversions, so I am intrigued by your suggestion which runs contrary to that. Maybe just a matter of taste, but would like to check it out.

    The film was exposed as 1600 but developed as 3200 in Ilford DD-X. The large image here was mangled by photo.net somehow, and the crop I uploaded only gives an idea about the grain, but nevertheless I find your observation about the grain intersting as well.

    Bathtime

          4

    The "large" version looks awful, wonder why since the original is within specs and should not have been resized... Medium size looks a little better.

    1423925.jpg

    Bathtime

          4

    A lot of grain is not compatible with photos of children, or so many

    seem to think. I think the grain achives a softness that is very

    appropriate for this this shot. What do you think?

    Swinging

          17
    I prefer this one. At a first look we cannot explain her hair by gravity so it has to be something like centrifugal forces which makes it a lot more dramatic, at least to a physicist such as myself :-) Thank you for the positive recent comment on my digital b/w, coming back to your portfolio and seeing the quality of your b/w film photography gives it great value to me.

    Squid

          4
    This is what went into this image: A glass form half-filled with water sitting on my light-table. I put a drops of blue food dye into the water, some disperse on the surface (lines) and some settle on the bottom. In this case the dye pooled in to a not-so interesting looking blob so I drew a few lines in it with an unfolded paper clip. It is the negative image, but otherwise no editing.
  1. I agree with the comment about viewing this against a dark background. I like the feel of this room as conveyed by your photo. The "interesting" elements as I see them are scattered around the edges of the photo, not sure if that is optimal.

    Intensity

          3

    I mainly wanted to emphasize the intense look I got from these blue

    eyes. Golden hour light made for very warm colors otherwise, but this

    treatment hopefully brings out a contrasting view.

  2. On the topic of interesting idioms in different languages: the English expression "to pull somebody's leg" is "to pull somebody by the nose" in Swedish, and I was once told that an similar Spanish expression has to do with hair in the same vein... Now, illustrate that! :-)
  3. hmmm - her patterened pantyhose is either bunched up or we may be looking at a hermaphrodite... I wonder about some of the elements but this is so strong it seems you don't really have to explain anything. I do wonder how you accomplished the line texture however... Good to see you posting.
×
×
  • Create New...