Jump to content

photo.net_hater

Members
  • Posts

    33
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by photo.net_hater

    Three Poles

          133
    I like the scene, but I don't like the execution - it's just too grey to me.

    In my mind's eye of this place, the sky is deep black, with shining wisps of white cloud. The poles are also dark, but backlit by the low sun. The water has great depths of tonality.

    And I know very well that I couldn't take this photo if my life depended on it. I also know that quite a few photo.netters probably could.

    This is the kind of tonality I'm thinking about.

    Three Poles

          133

    Tris, I actually agree with you. It seems that many people think they should give a 10 to 10% of all the pictures. Of course, they need to be taken aside and sternly lectured on the normal distribution.

     

    On the other hand, since photo.net keeps everyone's scores by name, how hard would it be to normalize each person's scores to a normal distribution? In other words, should Joe Blow's 9 really count the same as your 9?

     

    Hell, even HotOrNot.com normalizes scores before averaging, and they have to grapple with anonymous voters.

     

    All this doesn't change the fact that the rating system is probably flawed anyway. I would prefer something like:

     

    Would hang on my office/cubible wall. yes/no

    Would decorate bedroom with framed print. yes/no

    Would frame 8x10 and present to girlfriend. yes/no

    Would print on T-shirt and wear same to college basketball game. yes/no

×
×
  • Create New...