Hello all
I'm not sure if this is the correct place to post this. (Wasn't there an “Accessories category “ that had filters as a topic listed?) If there is a better place to post this question, please advise me.
Here goes:
I have read numerous times that it makes no difference to the film / sensor whether a linear or circular polarizer is is used, yet I remember taking pictures in the '70s, & '80sw/ linear polarizers that showed skin tones & other tones to be much darker . It also seemed easier to tune the effect of linear polarizers than it is today w/ circular ones. I realize that the last sentence could be caused by reduced acuity of my eye sight and/ or the possibility of poorer quality of today's ground glass's screens. But the much grater contrast & darkness of of images of human skin had nothing to do my vision. Admittedly I had many more female friends who were happy to be photographed wearing bikinis than I do today:-(
I was using Kodachrome (the Kodachrome lab was ~ 5 mi north of me in Hollywood, very convenient) & other transparency films, but I also shot quite a bit of neg. color film & I remember them coming out contrastier too, although not as contrasty as the transparency film.
All this causes me to believe that linear polarizers, work better than circular ones. I doubt that I'm right abut this & every writer on this topic is wrong. Could someone please give me a plausible explanation of this for the confusion that I'm having?
Thank you, JD McGraw
Mod note: moved to "Accessories Forum"