ravi_s
-
Posts
192 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Blogs
Events
Downloads
Gallery
Store
Image Comments posted by ravi_s
-
-
Very beautiful composition and a hard hitting story..!
r
-
A very magical photo of aurora.the city and the reflections add more drama to the composition
regards
r 7/7
-
A very beautiful composition indeed.
The layers of colours and the light is amazing.
r
-
7/7 Is this an other planet?..Wow..!
r
-
-
Very creative..!
-
Hello Szabo
I have looked at my ratings of more than 400 photographers and i have rated two of your photographs
1.Brown hill 4 average rating 4.4
2autum evening 2 average rating 5.44
I guess you would be interested in the 2 for autum evening
Though the photograph is technically fine (sans any errors with focus,colour,uneven tones etc ) my main reason for rating it 2 was the 'OVERIMPOSING FOREGROUND'.The uninteresting foreground occupied nearly 40% of the image obviously compromising the middle ground and background.This has compromised the beauty of the composition.
The rating as you know is random. It is not unusual to sometimes rate a photo low but the average rating is high(the alternative is true aswell)
If this happens i tend to go back and look at the comments to see why the photograph has been rated different to my rating..Ideally rating and critique should go together to give a rationale explanation of your assesment ...because of the time constrains , i can only rate the images.
The general rule of thumb i follow -
Technical flaw -1(most in photo net are above 1)
technically fine some aesthetic flaw or mundane (seen it million times )-2-3
Technically and aesthetically good 3-4
5-6 excellent ....stops you or makes you come back
7-never seen any thing like that ...wow factor(you have some in your portfolio),human interest stories,stories of relationship, exceptional timing,innovative and aesthetically suprerb etc.
The bottom line is 'beauty is in the eye of beholder'
closing now
ravi
-
My lengthy explanation in your portfolio
Many thanks
Ravi
-
This picture is Amazing ..!
-
A Great story
Very Good use of empty space
-
A good example of layers
unfortunately the resolution has deteriorated because of panaromic view
-
A very different perspective of Fall ...Well captured -
-
A very interesting play of lines,shadows and light 6/7 -
A beautiful portrait. The colour of the green knife could have been different(Unless used for aristic intent) 6/7
-
A Good composition.The landscape is very well captured by various tones of blue.6/7 -
A very good composition and a cute model. Good use of rule of 3rd. colours are vivid and bright.
i personally find the stand at the back with the cloth is distracting and makes the picture ...rather busy.
-
It is a beautiful simplistic composition.
To me the mist is somewhat not convincing.
-
-
-
excellent composition 7/7 -
-
A very good street photograph.The photo stops you and make you think.
A nice story well captured..! 6/7
-
Mt Pilatus
in Landscape
Posted
Hello Dr Kallol
This is not a HDR.Usual long exposure followed by a little tweak in PS
Regards
Ravi