Jump to content

Emmanuel Enyinwa

PhotoNet Pro
  • Posts

    9,425
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Emmanuel Enyinwa

  1. Again, I did not wish to cause offense, but I studied those pictures carefully. I might have different refrigerators from David Seltzer, but I believe if one of those pictures were posted for critique here, and treated strictly as photographs of dance, not BARYSHNIKOV's photos of dance, I would hardly expect it to be on the home page. Now, this is not necessarily the end all and be all of the value of photographs, and perhaps, I'm a bit jaded, but those are my opinions.
  2. Just my two cents. I think the idea of a rating system is somewhat silly because we are all sensitive to criticism. The funny thing about photography is that a lot of it is influenced by the quality of your equipment.

     

    Someone with a sinar on the average will get better tones than someone with an old Practika, for instance. Then, add in the fact that some people are simply better at Photoshop than someone like me, for instance. Yet, it is the reality that raters look at an image and judge it on its merits without regard to how it got that way. Unfair? yes, but that's the way it works.

     

    One MAJOR quibble I have, though, is the "originality" rating. Now, how is a photograph original, exactly, and why should lack of originality be a bad thing? How original were Ansel Adam's pictures? What about Irvin Penn or Brett Weston, who more or less copied his dad? But, yet, are you going to find better prints anywhere?

     

    I've learned to not worry so much about the ratings. Some of my more highly rated pictures are not even my favorites, which are really the street candids and happy accidents I've encountered over the years. Some pictures have meaning to me, stories I cannot tell to an anonymous viwer in front of his computer screen. Should I not post these pictures because over the years they have acquired a little dust spot? Or because I shot it with a tiny disposable camera? Of course, NOT!

     

    I find that my more "mature", tonally superior photographs can coexist with my more playful, spontaneous snapshots, of which I have many more. That is who I am, and why I take pictures.

×
×
  • Create New...