Jump to content

ned

Members
  • Posts

    82
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ned

  1. Brent,

     

    As others mentioned, unless the user has *not* reset file numbering there's no way to verify unless you take the camera to a Canon Service Facility or can find someone with the 1D Service CD. However, the 1D spec is 150,000 accutations and worst case, it's a $150 repair if you go through Canon. I've been using two 1D's for over a year and frankly have never even worried about this. One of the bodies easily has over 130K shots and it still works like new. If in fact you ever get to this point, it probably means the camera has served you well and just like my '88 BMW 535IS with over 160,000 miles I can decide *if* it's worth rebuilding the transmission or not :-)

     

    Also, I think the issue of shutter count is only one of the factors when buying a used 1D. If the rest of the camera body is pristine and obviously cared for, then you're probably ok. If it's beat, then I'd be suspicious anyway and probably look for another sample.

     

    Hope this helps,

     

    Ned

    http://www.bunnellphotography.com

  2. Subject: Response to EOS 1D - edge sharpness

     

    Ian, I suspect it's not your 1D. Assuming you're doing your test wide open, other folks have gotten sample 16-35's which were soft at f/2.8. You might want to test both lens using your brick wall scene, with camera mounted on tripod and take shots from 2.8 up to 16 to see if the image improves as it's stopped down. That would definitely confirm it's a lens problem which by the way canbe corrected by Canon Service.

    As an example, I'm including two links (hope they work) which show a "before" and "after" shot from my 17-35 which was very soft on the left side. Canon replaced the fourth element and now I'm back to normal with this lens. I'm not suggesting your new lens need this type of service, but running your lenses through all apertures should help narrow the problem down.

     

    Hope this helps you and enjoy the 1D and those lenses.

     

    Ned

     

    http://www.pbase.com/image/6642508

     

    http://www.pbase.com/image/6642519

  3. The 2x ext works fine with my 70-200 f/2.8 IS L. Also, I'm not sure what you'd use the 70-200 for, but you should really consider the f/2.8 IS version. Yes it's heavier & more money, but this lens is incredibly sharp, has great contrast, beautiful background blur and the "IS" really works. If you're near a pro shop that rents Canon lens, I'd recommend you try both lenses for a day to help make your decision.
×
×
  • Create New...