Published: Friday 28th of December 2007 05:51:20 PM
steven cassidy, I wouldn't argue about : " this is terrible, its not a photo, its photoshop nonsense ".. but what do you mean saying "taken way too far"..? Did the image couse some problems for anybody ?
Thank you all for your comments
stunning beautiful image. congrats
Wonderful concept. Beautifully executed. Nicely done. Dan
ceslovas As always, you demonstrate remarkable photo editing skills and a wonderful whimsical imagination. Terrific work here.
for real? Amazing shot! Composed perfect, sense of scale is spot on. Dramatic with grey's and muted colors. Congrats. Wouldn't change a thing.
my apologies, not meaning to get at you personally as you made the picture so you know exactly how it was made. imho i can see very little in this picture that is real and while it makes a pretty picture my 12 year old daughter can also create some fab pictures with either paints or cs3. this imho is meant to be a photographic forum not a digital painting forum so while as long as idiotic programs like photoshop and the like will always be with us to lets say help those less fortunates that either dont know how to or cant be bothered to take real pictures that can actually amaze us with their brilliance. as i said this is a pretty composite-it would look well on a postcard. no it didnt hurt or harm anyone so i'll take back the 'taken too far' comment, but seriously i'll bet that you're killing yourself laughing at the critical comments posted before mine- i know i am
Ceslovas is a master of "digital darkroom", category about which is discussed in this forum and which requires even more creativity and technical capability than plain photography.
S.C. No, I'm not laughing at the critical comments posted before yours, actually your comment made me smile. It is more photo than you think you know. I know I don't have to explain but the only non-photo thing is tornado's tail, realizing it's not a single shot I post it at digital altenations category. You said you had a twelve years old daughter, it means your pretty grown and I hope you didn't create your account on photo.net for only writing one complaint message on single photo. Good luck!
I love it:)
Great composition !!!
neimk i galva tu komentaru:) darbas kaip visada puikus!7/7
i'll get hammered for saying this but this is terrible, its not a photo, its photoshop nonsense taken way to far
For image manipulation this is actually very good. Some blurring (motion blur) on the tornado funnel would help make this more realistic.. IMO I love the composition and the mirroring of the path with the funnel. Great work.
hi -More Than Excellent shot.
I could give this one 10 for originality. I love the title too. JUST PERFECT ! Jana
Gary Grubb Wonderful ! I love the softness of the colors, the way the light is touching the old windmill. It is both calming and disturbing at the same time. Wish I had your talents in the image editing department.
Woooww..:-))) I'm think it makes some jealous:-( Isn't there a section "digital alternation" so? Regards, ben
Hi Ceslovas Very fine composition and excellent alteration! Congrats!