Farm with squared ballons

Please costructive comments, not polemic.

Tuscany, always beautiful!!

Beautiful colors and composition.

Bella questa!!! So anche esattamente dove l'hai fatta....he..he...

Splendida! Vedo che anche con il digitale sei perfettamente a tuo agio. Complimenti ancora una volta Maria!

mi ha emozionata.

brava Maria!

Muy bonita. Bravo Maria

Great colours and composition.

Maria, nice picture! Thousght you may like my take on it...

 

http://www.photo.net/photodb/photo?photo_id=1812666

Complimenti Maria!

Good composition good color. Keep it going Maria.

Beautiful landscape! Congratulations Maria!

 

Lovely composition

It's a very pleasant scene, Maria, but sevens on aesthetics? That question is not intended to be a putdown. I just think that a lot of your other photos are better, and, if this is a seven on aesthetics, then how high a number would be appropriate for your very best?

Great comp. Maria! the sky are amazing and the colors so soft and pleasent.

 

Cheers, allon.

Good use of perspective and nice colors. I am not sure about the acre at the bottom, perhaps you could crop here and concentrate on the tractor lines of the field leading the eyes

Excellent composition, perspective and colours.

:)

Maria, simply beautiful, very nice composition, we continue!! Pnina

Oh, My. Just another blatant exercise in mate rating.

This is simply an uninteresting snapshot. A throw-away. It's over-exposed. The colors are washed out. The lighting is dull and flat. The foreground is empty. There is no point of interest. It says nothing.

Is this just a "test" to see how far this silly rating game can be pushed on PN with inane congrats from as many friends as possible just to prove a point?

VL

i do not like polemics. Are unuseful cryng. Only costructive comments are matter of adults. Will we leave the childwood to the babies. Will we, please?!

Wonderful! It makes me want to be back in Tuscany.

for you colors strong and not washed. BUT ONLY FOR YOU.

Maria,

Stop playing this silly little game. Polemic? You set up a controversial situation, then you dare anyone to challenge it. Shame on you.

Constructive criticism? Sometimes there is nothing constructive to say about a particular image. There is nothing to suggest about the composition or point of interest, because there simply is none. If you think this image is correctly exposed, then you need to learn about exposure. But I don't really think that's the case.

And pumping up the saturation on an image that already has blown out highlights, simply makes it garrish as you have shown

Move on. Stop this game. It doesn't benefit you or anyone here to continue this kind of nonsense (expecting high ratings just because you have fostered a virtual realtionship with strangers across the Internet). This image is a stinker, technically and aesthetically. I have no problem giving honest evaluations of photographic images. I do it for a living.

Any photographer who has any ability knows exactly the value of an image before posting it. You knew your friends would praise this, no matter that it is very weak. Although I refuse to use this site's rating system, this image is worth about 3/3 and you know it very well.

On the other hand, if you truly believe this image has merit, on any grounds, I have seriously overrated your abilities. I could give a complete novice a point-and-shoot camera and expect to see this kind of work, maybe a little better.

VL