John in his living room recrop

This is a crop per a suggestion about this image. Any comments are

appreciated.

undecided. Good photography

I saw this posted and went searching for the original.  While the tones, composition and subject matter are fantastic in both, I find the sense of place much more defined in the original.  I have to note that you can't go wrong with either.  Excellent work...  Mike

Excellent portrait. He feels at home . . . and so do you.

Cynthia, I enjoyed looking at pictures of John's series. I like the lighting, the composition, the pose of John, and of course the surroundings.

From the two pictures,  I like the previous image.

Regards,

Rosario.

Cynthia, having seen the original the first thing that crossed my mind was to crop a little the upper section of the photo.  After that I caught myself looking for some space in the lower section of the photography.  My eye needed more space down and the immediate thought I did was to imagine how the shot would be if you have lower the camera a bit, giving more space and info into the lower section and  reduce the view of the ceiling.

Seeing this I would suggest, strictly personal opinion, to keep the photo as shot in the first place.  Have a nice day!  Cheers!