Smithy

ciao marco. i want to observe the quality of bw here, really very well working. what you did here is not easy. you respected the old, used appareance of you subject - also the ruined wood - using a very rich gamma, starting from a discrete white and with an many grey tones that reveals all the details. well done.

Andrea, Thank you very much for your appreciation. Best regards, Marco

I echo Andrea's comment - technically well done, and compositionally very interesting.  The wrenches appear like chimes or a glockenspiel.  In a place with a lot of metallic banging going on, chimes might fit in well.

This is kind of perfect. It looks like you saw the picture you wanted to take, and then you took it, which is a good thing. A little fuzzy over on the right side by the bicycle chain (I think). Otherwise, a nice landscape of crescent wrenches. :)

While this is a wonderful composition, i also have strong reservations for the top right corner. I would crop it on the right to remove the plastic bag onwards. compliments -koushik

Mark, J Sevigny, Koushik, Thank you for your comments and remarks. I can crop of course but in this case I wanted to show what I noticed: an authentic situation. It is what it is. Best regards, Marco