Untitled

I'm brand spanking new here and this image was one of the first

I have taken with my new Tokina 17mm. Will be interested in

observations.

Well done on the exposure and composition.

I like the composition, it has a smooth as glass feel to it.

I just love this shot!!! It is great, I just wished I was there to shoot it, I am also a rookie myself and trying to build a library of photos before posting them up. Great shot by the way!!!

AWESOME JOB BUT I WISH THE SUN WAS A BIT LOWER.

Tremendous colors, reflections of light and textures...

beautiful contrast and compostion

This guy is a pro.

Lovely shot, a little dark in the foreground but I know I couldn't do better

The very dark bottom and out of focus horizon detract some. I like the clouds.

very good use of ps,well done

It's a nice image with proper exposure but it's largely a sunset image with complementary elements that compositionally don't add enough dynamic content to make a great image.

 

Your using a 17mm but your chosen composition isn't really emphasizing a near/far relationship because of the required exposure, the amount of sky in the image and the somewhat redundant foreground. Consequently the image feels aesthetically flat.

Very good, PS or not. The "3" above is absurd. An argument that this photo is "below average" can't be substantiated.

 

Superb colours.

 

Perhaps this lens is mediocre or LF necessary ?