juddirishbradley

Thomas you asked for a comment - I rate folders on aesthetics and originality- being that I teach an Aesthetics class as a part of Photography I, this is my reason for my rating. I rate aesthetics on whether I would hang it on my wall in my home. With a 4 rating - I might if it suited the room. As far as originality is concerned, I do not find macro shots to be too original. Maybe I have seen too many of them recently. The critique is more about personal tast than professional opinion. As a professional I rate you work as a whole very highly. This image just doesn't do it for me. Good enough explanation? I hope so.

Judd Irish Bradley

 

Great Profile but too much photoshop on the edge of her forehead. It looks like the eraser was too soft on some parts and too hard on others.

Good Image I lke what you have done with the Brush work

nice texture

This Shot I belive is better than the other two I saw. I cannot really explain why- It seems to have more emotion to it. The others seem colder, less personal, and therefore do not work as well.

I usually rate photos in the fine art cat. I keep in mind whether I would hang a piece in my home. this one fits the bill. good work.

nice colors but seems to be more commercial than fine art

beautiful shot dont take the down play of thr iginality in my rating as a bad thing. I have seen too many leaves today.

nice contrast very 50's