jeffgermo

Thanks for the effort Dieter. I did resubmit it and I see you gave another critique. Thanks for your support. I appreciate it. This one is getting more ratings, but the views are not showing up. I'm not sure why some photos of mine which i think are inferior will receive 11,000 views while this other only gets 400 in the same amount of time. One of the mysteries of life I guess. :) Thanks again.

To Tim: In responding to a posting, make sure that you respond only to the content of the thread and not the individual. In particular, we don't want to see the discussion of anyone's motives. They aren't knowable and aren't relevant.

Not very helpful, but thanks Tim.

I have tried almost every search by categeory and all my photos that were in the top rated photos are no longer there even though they are rated higher than others. I don't get it.

It's strange. I have tried almost every search by categeory and all my photos that were in the top rated photos are no longer there even though they are rated higher than others. I don't get it.

I actually requested a critique immediately upon posting the photo. and received the only four critiques within minutes of the request. After that there was no more action, and it was not listed in the "top rated photos" which some of my others were that were posted at the same time and were not rated as high. Anywho, we'll wait and see if we get a response.

I'm glad I'm not the only one experiencing this. It's the exact questioin for me. The photo in question http://www.photo.net/photo/5326394 I feel is my personal best and I'd like to get some feedback on it. It received only 4 ratings all very high with an average of 6.75. It only got just over 400 views when other lesser photos of mine got over 10,000 views in the same period of time and were placed in the top photos listings. Anyway, I hope we get some answers cause I feel a little cheated. :)

Jeff

I am relatively new to photo.net and am not quite sure how things work. I have

requested several critiques for photos and something doesn't quite make sense to

me. I requested a critique for this photo;

http://www.photo.net/photo/5326394 on Dec. 12, 06 and have only

gotten 439 views and 4 ratings A-6.75 and O-6.75 average. It has not shown up

in the top rated photos even though it has a high rating.

 

Two other photos have shown up and have lower ratings, but over 20 times the

views in the same number of days. This one:

http://www.photo.net/photo/5327507

 

And this one: http://www.photo.net/photo/5324317.

 

Why would the first photo only have 439 view and the others around 10,000 each

when the first photo (in my estimation and in those who rated it) is a far

superior photo? Did it drop out of sight in the critique forum for some reason?

 

Also, how are the "top photos" chosen to be shown? I assumed it would be

according to ratings, but that is obviously not the only criterium.

 

Can someone help me out with these questions?

 

Thanks,

Jeff<div></div>