Jump to content

ingermargrete

Members
  • Posts

    1,885
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by ingermargrete

  1. Hello Gisela, I understand what you are talking about. I think you should do what you feel comfortable with, keep on commenting on other peoples photos and you will feel comfortable with giving ratings in no time:) And - if you don`t get any response to some of your photos you can delete them, upload them again and request a new critique, perhaps at another time of the day like Ian suggested. Best regards, Inger:)
  2. "but I like to see the progress that someone has made - all the little steps that get to the most recent best work."

    Maybe this could be a new presentation of yours, with your own photos, where you offer your advice and ideas?

    When I give someone a critique I think that I am giving it to this person (and not so much anyone else) and if he/she wants to delete the photo, it`s Ok, because I know that he/she has read my critique. Maybe a "learning"-presentation is something you could do? I`m just throwing out an idea:):)

  3. It would be nice to see more sport-photos here. But this is an international website and the sports that people find interesting may vary from country to country - at least a little, I think. In my country I would say that soccer, biking, motorsports and handball are amongst the interesting ones at this time.
  4. I agree that different aspects of a photo can happen by accident - not everything can be planned or decided upon. I also think that burned-out highlights will work in some situations (and I wrote that) but I did think that this was something one usually should avoid - as a general guideline, if you will. My experience from other websites is also this - that burned-out higlights are being looked at as a negative thing in general.
  5. To me it sounds like the light is too harsh. Either the lights needs to be further away from the flower, lower in intensity or you need something to diffuse the lights more. With backlit objects you may also need something to light up the front of the flower so that this doesn`t get too dark, like a reflector. I have done this myself, using the sun and without a reflector(Orange Gerbera flower:)
  6. "..blown out highlights... so what, for it may be pleasing to someone."

     

    I thought that blown out highlights was something one should not do in photography, it means that the exposure is not correct. This was more the case before than it seems to be now, I think. It is suitable for some situations, if it enhances the photo - but often it doesn`t.

×
×
  • Create New...