frans_hartman

Thanks for all reactions. For Mark....I did not say that everybody MUST like my pictures! Everybody is different and that should be. But a reaction in the form of a critique when ratedlow (or high!) would give me the chance to improve my qualities. I don't think this has to do, as you wote, with attitude. If you would take time to take a tour you would see that in my demand for critiques I always encourage people to say the truth. But again, it is strange to see that pictures (not only mine!) are rated from very bad to excellent. And I think that shows that non-professionals are mixing up with professinals rating the pictures. And once again, I don't mind when people would rate mine very low, as long as I can learn from it and make my work better!

thanks again!

Dear all,

As a serious member of this site I critique and rate pictures only

after having looked at it for 1 or 2 minutes minimum. When I rate it

I also give very often a comment.

My question is the following. It looks to me that lot of people here

are NOT serious and are not serious photographers. When I look at a

picture of mine published in a local magazine and highly appreciated

for the quality I see here a rating varying from 2/2 till 7/7!!

Something must be done here.

Is it possible to oblige (through the technique of ifnot=then)

readers here to leave a comment when given rates under 5? or 4?

Thanks, Frans Hartman