Jump to content

dan_paley

Members
  • Posts

    20
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Image Comments posted by dan_paley

    Sea & Sky

          62

    I'm looking hard for the Emperor's clothes and I just don't see them. The women's poses strike me as god-awful contrivances and I don't understand how they relate to whatever you are trying to convey. The title suggests that you mean to play off the contrast between sea and sky... warm/serene vs. cool/turbid? Maybe the women are meant to suggest projections of the water and its more energetic aspect into the more placid sky. (but why would the left-hand woman be looking back down??) If that interpretation is correct, the angular and strained poses are logical, but in an aesthetic sense they still make me wince. I can't get past those 20 fingers all akimbo. How uncomfortable your models must have been, I can't imagine.

     

    Could you try to explain the themes you had in mind for this picture?

    Hello...

          3
    Hmm. Seen it before. There are things I love about this; your image is well exposed and tack sharp and your subject is striking. But for this to be a great photo, your presentation of this familiar image had better be spot on, and the composition of this one just doesn't do it for me. I would suggest that you try to cut the dead space and (gasp) keep the rule of thirds in mind; here it might have helped to position the bird's eye on the upper left intersection. Hope I'm not stifling you. Good shot. DP
  1. Do you think it's a possibility that printed nice and large and glossy, toned, matted, displayed, it could rise above "nice"? (A completely serious question.)

     

    It's frustrating... I don't think this site and I are seeing eye to eye. I swear to God that Ansel Adams would have pulled steady 5's on PN.

  2. I have two fears for this picture. Number uno is that it's just a

    pretty cliche. My mom liked it; this is often the kiss of death.

    Number two is that the 50/50 horizon placement might be a little

    stiff. So... like it? Any thoughts on how better to capture this

    beautiful light without being so... boring?

×
×
  • Create New...