drdreas

everything is great except that you can see up her nose! That was the first thing that jumped out at me and its not very flattering.

I like the model's expression, I like the framing, although I think this photo suffers in the lighting department. The light is a little bit harsh to me, and I think a reflector held slightly below and the the left (the model's left) of the face would have given more flattering light. Also, the direct light is highlighting the link on the jacket, which is a bit distracting. Very nice otherwise.

This is a beautiful photo. I love the minimalism and focus on tone and composition. This is something I would frame and hang on my wall.

why the watermark?

nice color tone and texture

I would try to adjust black point in levels to darken the background.

I'm sorry, its too photoshopped for me. The masking is painfully obvious at the edges of the goats, and the background is so unatural that it does not compliment the subjects. Hope this doesn't sound too harsh.. maybe you'd like to post the original photo so we can havea look.

Beautiful photo, as all the others have said. One thing that caught my attention, is that you can still see the outline of the sun through the wings of the bird. Is this because the light is actually passing though the wings partially, or is it an artifact of another phenomenon?

 

In any case, I do not wish this to berate the photo in any way, I am simply curious.

Robin hood got beat up by little john right in the middle of that waterfall.

Nice shot, but I believe it is underexposed. I would try to expose so that the white squares are actually white, then bump up the contrast with the black squares.

Too much clutter, and very hard to determine what if anything the subject is.

I like the diagonal composition and the monotone.

This is an example of why I keep browsing the photo.net galleries. I can not find one thing I would change. So emotive, I am sure it yields a strong response from each viewer. Technically perfect. This is why I love photography. Thanks for sharing it.

I like the high contrast B&W. Have you tried cropping out the window entirely. It seems to me it would work well as a narrow panorama format.

 

Andreas

This is a copy of a shot taken 2 years ago in the exact same location. Here it is:

http://www.pbase.com/stfchallenge/image/19035695

 

Don't know if you saw it before, but its the exact same shot.

fake