Crater Lake

which composition works better - this one or with the island in the

center? Thank you for your opinions

http://photo.net/photodb/photo?photo_id=9835533

For me this composition works better. The lefthand foreground does not improve with more in view. The top left of the scene looks better with more land between the cloud and sea. The Island is placed much better in relation to the other elements. I clearly think this is a the better compostion by far. I like the reflected colours in the water was obviously a longer exsposure very nice. Regards