Island on Lake Kananaskis

A huge thanks to the photographers who critiqued my first cut of this

shot. I'll be glad to provide a return critique to anyone who

critiques this one. Thanks, Scott.

Nice colors.I like it very much.

Very nice sharp & clear.

I saw your other post amd agreed to remove the rocks. However I like the mountains. I would have just cropped the foreground and left the rest as is.The mountains give a better perspective to the island to me. Isn't this area of Canada gorgeous!BTW I too tried to get some responses to 2 photos-should I crop or not-you got a better and more detailed reply-but you are right that is what a lot of us are looking for. If you have time check out my site and give some of your thoughts. Paul

Hi Paul,

 

I'm happy to have a look at your site. I really debated keeping the mountains... this crop just felt more powerful to me. I think in the original crop the mountains were nicely balanced with the shoreline, and without the shoreline, it felt off balance to me.

 

Cheers,

Scott.

Good point-either way you have a great shot.This way the island stands out better.BTW I too try to get something in the forground and usually use a wide angle lens.

Thanks for commenting on my bridge shot.It helps to get other eyes looking and commenting on our work.

Paul