single photos eye of the valley

all critiques are welcome

Great photo...well done

Color dodging is evident.

Good picture with excellent composition. There is a bit more work to do here though. You have darkened the sky considerably to bring out the detail, maybe a bit too dark for me. Where you have selected the sky has left a light (original exposed) halo just above the horizon. If you try again zoom in close and select the horizon acuratley and feather the selction by 100 - 200 pixels so that you lose the sharp edge. Keep the vignette as it works well with the picture. Hope this helps. :0)