Majik Tree

cottonwood tree on the plains. comments?

It looks as though the clouds are the lost branches of the tree--very beautiful and indeed magical--emily

I couldn't say anything bad about this. I love it.

A landscape with a twist. Very interestingly seen and captured. Magical would be the word.

excelent work!light and composition its very good but this picture its not orizontaly.

Dramatic mood, lovely composition.

 

Regards

creative eye nice post work..and just dreamy

Well worth looking at larger... wonderful intricate sky & good detail in the foreground... horizon's a bit wonky & there's slight halo-ing on the stump. Was it one shot or 2 mixed?

Indeed its a magic tree

Good work Chuck !!

excellent execution. i especially like the subdued tonality contrasting with the cloud bank. congrats.

 

teegee

Not sure if I quite agree with some of the comments on this image.  I do like some of the colors, but I have seen some better work from you.  The horizon is not true, the background is too cluttered with uninteresting things which I think don't really add to the image, and centering of the subject not too sure if it works...as well as the exposure / post processing (it is a bit under exposed / heavy on the feathered vig).  However, I do like how the clouds & the tree compliment each other and I do like how you have captured the detail of the tree.  Just trying to give you feedback on how I see it...:-)

Dejan

I appreciate that you took the time to comment on this image, but your comments are pretty late. It was posted over 4-1/2 years ago and my processing has changed a lot since then. Today I wouldn't produce another image that looks like this.