Tayside Cottage

Thanks

Awesome image Gerry. You can almost feel the weight of the sky pressing down. Great exposure and tones. Keith

nice tones but i'd like to see more details... OD

Dramatic sky is the best thing about this shot. There are some significant problems though. The composition is OK, the foreground in particular is not that interesting to make such a big feature. I find the toning strange especially in the sky where there are strange looking darker areas that don't look quite right. I think it needs to be reworked from scratch preferably in pure B&W. It does have potential to be quite a good image but this is not working for me as it stands.

Excellent lighting and tones. A really wonderful photograph. Congrats.

bravo

Hello Gerry, strong and powerfull work.

Bravo.

f.

i'm begining to think there's something fishy about PN lately :(

kah kit.. couldn't disagree with you more.nothing needs to be reworkedthe foreground gives a perfect starting point and emphasizes the perspective.naturally mine is just another point of view.

Cristian, if we all gave comments like wow, great, Gerry would learn anything from the exercise of putting something up for critique. I saw this as quite a good shot but with potential to be a much better image which is why I offered some constructive criticism. There are clear problems in the conversion, look at all those messy shadow areas with no detail.

kha I didn't express myself correctly, I wasn't implying that you should have said wow, nor awesome, nor nice colors (!). Simply expressed my disagreement with your constructive comment, and tried to rebut it constructivly. Greetings.

Wonderful dramatic stormy sky dear Gerry :)

 

Biliana