national park (zion, bryce, arches, canyonland, grand canyons) Natural Frame

What do you think? With or without the top frame? Comments and

suggestions welcome. Thanks.

My recommendation is to crop off the top frame. It is a neat feature, but for me it distracts/detracts from the rest of the image. Also, overall, the picture seems to be over-sharpened: There are too many glossy little points.

Chuck for your input. I do have several other shots at this same location with different comps and will work on them later if I get a chance.