pnital 36 Posted June 13, 2005 Photographed in Japan. The Golden Pavilion was declared " World Cultural Heritage" in 1994. It is a breath taking temple and Garden. It was croped a bit titely on the upper part to avoid the lack of sky the day it was photographed. Please comment your thoughts, Thanks Pnina Link to comment
pnital 36 Posted June 13, 2005 Was built by the Shogun of Ashikaga in 1397. After his death it became a Zen Temple. The 2nd and 3rd floors are covered with gold leaves on Japanese lacquer. Situated in Kyoto. Link to comment
rkynast 1 Posted June 13, 2005 A beautiful, peaceful capture. Respectfully, it might have been stronger if most of the water had been cropped, leaving only the temple and the branches of the tree on the left. Link to comment
carsten_ranke 0 Posted June 13, 2005 Hmmm, tighter crop... I don`t think so, the tree on the left fits nicely into the composition, IMO. The ripples of the water are not empty space, all together I find the composition balanced. Regards Carsten Link to comment
julio_segura_carmona1 2 Posted June 13, 2005 Excelente imagen Pinna,,, preciosa luz y reflejos,,, Ah,,, por cierto nacieron los tres polluelos,,, y cuando vino la madre me fui,,,ayer estuve ayi,,, y corren como diablos,,, un cordial saludo. Link to comment
delp 0 Posted June 13, 2005 This is a great image Pnina. As always, my scientific eye would tend to prefer a different crop, (i.e. more space above the roof) but again; 1- I don't know the place and 2-this crop is absolutely not destructive. One other thing I would have loved to try while being there was with an ND4 filter and long exposure to obtain a smooth water surface. But I need to buy the ND4 filter and then travel to Japan ... that will be maybe after Vienna ! Cheers. L. Link to comment
pnital 36 Posted June 13, 2005 Prachi, Richard, Carsten, Julio and Lionel. Carsten, thanks, I think like you that the water riples are adding to the composition as is. Lionel, as I have written I have titly croped the upper part on purpose. The riples in the water were done because of the light wind that was there why do you want it smooth? I like it.... anyway about the ND filter we shall soon talk about.... Link to comment
kyang 0 Posted June 13, 2005 Pnina, This is a very nice travel photo. Good sharpness with the nice detail. I like how you crop it and the composition is very effective. The only improvement I can think about is the lighting. But for traveler like us, we just don't have time to wait... Enjoy it. Link to comment
atkphotoworks 0 Posted June 13, 2005 As always, beautiful colours. Part of me wished that the water was more tranquil so that you could have captured a sharper reflection. Link to comment
adolfovalente 0 Posted June 13, 2005 Very nice landscape, well composed. The light is excellent Link to comment
dk. 0 Posted June 13, 2005 Pnina, it's a very nice picture. I was wondering what you thought of this crop? I did it very fast and cut a bit to much off the top and right side but you get the idea about the water and the tree. To me the tree sticks out to much in the picture because of the water in front of it and in so doing takes to much attention, So if you crop it as I did I think it brings much more attention to the building, so what do you think? Anyway it's a very nice picture. DK. Link to comment
LenMarriott 9 Posted June 13, 2005 Pnina, I echo all the positive comments above as it is a beautiful scene. I must agree with Lionel regarding the tight crop on top. Increasing the space between the top of the building and the frame would relieve the point of tension caused in the current version. Perhaps an elevated platform for the camera would have allowed you to do this and still keep the sky from intruding. A treasured keeper in any case I'm sure. Best, LM. Link to comment
alexandra rauh 0 Posted June 14, 2005 Pnina,looks like,You keep some of Your treasures for later.Just perfect. I like all the water,the reflection of the pavilion,both trees , left and right. Peaceful and beautiful.The motif fits Your style. Alix Link to comment
cherlyn 1 Posted June 14, 2005 I like the original crop as it is. Agree with Carsten that it is quite balanced. Beautiful travel shot. Natural tones & exposure. Link to comment
hiro_aki 0 Posted June 14, 2005 I really like the angle of the building and the sharp image. I believe the building was made so that when you see this building from this place, the bird on the top of the roof is actually barely within the background mountains. You might have moved quite a bit to the right so that this was not true. Also the wind was unfortunate. The pond is called something like "Mirror Lake Pond" and was designed to see the reflection of the building. When there's no wind, many people actually prefer the reflected image than the actual building. And I think it is true that the objects in the lake such as pine trees as in this picture are designed to make harmony with the building itself and also the reflection. So in my opinion, the wind and the ripples are unfortunate. If there was no wind and the reflection was clear, I'm pretty sure a photographer like yourself must have taken entirely different picture. Link to comment
pnital 36 Posted June 14, 2005 Kurt,Amar,Adolfo, David Len( nice to see you here Len)Cherlyn , Hiro and Alix. David,Thanks for taking the time, it is too titly croped IMO, and the difference is not significante I think. The water and Garden are importent part of the complex and I wanted it to be seen,The upper tight crop was needed for my comming explanation... To all of you thanks for all suggestions !!, but let me tell you that weather vision was terrible while being there. All the trees behind the temple were covered with haze, windy and lack of sky... I have worked hard in post precessing it, so its beauty can be seen. So I appreciate all your comment and suggestions, It is not perfect... but its beauty can be seen. Thank you Hiro for YOUR explanation. Pnina Link to comment
maria conversano 0 Posted June 14, 2005 Magic reflections, exellent composition and lovely warm colors! Great work, Pnina. Link to comment
colin carron 58,916 Posted June 14, 2005 Pnina, you have captured a sense of peace here. I agree the crop is tight at the top but it is not enough to make a problem. I think I would have tried a slightly wider angle (no surprise there!) I prefer including the foreground water as you have it. As to mist and bad weather sometimes they help to make nice photos.... A fine shot. regards - Colin Link to comment
hiroya 0 Posted June 14, 2005 You have captured a very beautiful image of this temple under some difficult conditions. I think I would crop this way too. As Hiro explained, reflection on the still water is a spectacle, if sky was clearly fine. I almost agree with Hiro, but in this photo, temple and gray sky look like gold flakes and silver flakes on the water because of ripples. This is another beauty of reflection. I think people have been enjoying view of this temple in many different ways. Link to comment
pnital 36 Posted June 14, 2005 Thanks to allof you, I realy appreciate your comments! Colin my 10-22 lens was not yet mine being here... so it is only the 18-55... and focal lent was 34mm. Hiroya, my human meetings in Japan were one of THE high lights of my visit. I'm glad we could meet and keep a friendship.Thanks for everything. Link to comment
ada-ipenburg 0 Posted June 14, 2005 It's a beautiful image, dear Pnina. I love all that water in front. It gives that wonderful old temple such a peaceful look. Link to comment
jeremy freeland 0 Posted June 15, 2005 I like the image, not least for the golds and yellows, and the quasi impressionist trees behind the building. I wouldn't change the crop - I like how the ripples curve in from the bottom of the frame to the calmer water extending off the l/h tree, and then get going again to bring the eye along the water (catching a wider stretch of the reflected golds) to the temple. The white panels and wooden framing add some nice linear elements as well, bringing out the chosen perspective facing the corner of the building. Best, Jeremy. Link to comment
Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now