Golden october at Dyck Castle, Juechen

Golden october

Good symmetry. Impressive foliage; it looks like it is really bearing down upon those on the path.

I think this image will take you far. It is very good!

Great capture, mood, exposure and control. This is similar to the Windows screen saver (but I like this better). The couple (family) and car add to the scale and definition of the trees (very powerful). Congratulations all the way around!

Awesome color, great composition with the car and walkers, symmetry definitely works. Simply outstanding. Kudos.

Impressive autumnal image with a great color in golden tones.

For my opinion the car breaks the composition.

Regards.

powerful autumn trance! very fertile art. great shot.

Hola Franz,

de que es una de las mejores fotos, que vi de usted. Simplemente sensationally. Mach má³ futuro así °ues, eso vale el doble 7. Pedro

Great moment. Great picture. Congratulations

7/6 superb photo

Lovely, simple fall shot.

Very nice!

Superb autumnal shot, great colors and good use of perspective. Regards, Carsten

the truncated trunks make my eyes leap into the orange mass and then i want to shift quickly somewhere else for visual relief!

franz, no one but you posted the link to this photo in the site feedback forum. that is asking not just me but everyone else to critically look at your complaint and the subject photo

I didn't make a complaint. I asked a question.

well okay. to answer franz's specific question, the answer is NO he cannot ask the anonymous rater to explain his rating scores, so he cannot do anything but accept it and perhaps ponder the meaning of it relative to his photo. contemplation can be good. one can learn from it

 

It is a strange rate. I would have assumed 1 for originality, but it turns out to be for aesthetics.

 

The real question that should be asked is,"does the image justify 45 rates and an average over 6, but even more importantly, does this image deserve so much visibility relative to a thousand or so other images that won't get the number of views that this did?

 

What can I learn about this image? What is unusual about what the photographer saw and captured?

 

If your answer is not much, then let's look at something more interesting.

Excuse me but this looks like any other pic any amature could take in any park in any city on the east coast with a run of the mill coolpix. Its got poor resolution and i question whether the thing is even level..and can't be bothered checking. Whats the big deal here with all the rates?? 4/4

Looks oversaturated. */*

The number of eyes you have caught, looking at your wonderful photo and making ANY comment is a compliment in itself. I think it is wonderful.

Excellent. I was recently there while the leaves were still green.

Your image certainly evokes the sense of autumn. Thanks. John Wilkins

A gorgeous fall image! I love the color! Simply beautiful!

 

Thank you for your comment on my recent critique request ... not many folks follow through and read requests with specific questions. I appreciate the time you spent!

 

Regards!

How beautiful!