b) next best (4.5 & over) Gaucho +5

Ian,

I prefer the crop on this version to the other version. For the most part I like the increase in saturation. The only suggestion would be to decrease the red saturation on the man's skin. He looks like he has a very bad sunburn.

Otherwise great shot!

Regards,

Charlie

Agreed! - I think your constructive criticism is spot-on and your version is a definite improvement