Wishes to revive

Your critiques and comments are always welcomed. Thanks in advance.

Congrats

 

The B & W tones play a pivotal role here in enhancing the starkness of the trees within the landscape. The plume of clouds adds to this once more giving a soft backdrop to the tree limbs that reach in vain for heaven.  I notice the shadows of the trees on the left and wonder if it would have been possible to include them, I think they would have made an interesting addition, but realise of course there could be unwanted elements to the left. To summarise this is a well thought out image with a strong composition and an atmosphere of remoteness

Well done Hamid!

Best Regards

Alf

The B/W works well with your composition. It gives the photo the right atmosphere of isolation...Well done! Kind regards.

Well seen Hamid, the branches and clouds play very well for this shot, the B/W is a good option in this case. I agree with Alf about the shadows of the trees, is just my opinion, anyway this is a beautiful shot. Congratulations my friend. My rate: 6.

Fantastic composition with nice sky textures.Backdrop is revealing vastness.Very nicely rendered in B&W.

My best regards.

Kallol

A very nicely composed beautiful shot, Hamid!

Best regards,

Ruud.

 

Beautiful composition and brilliant bw tonality. The triangular shape of the cloud starting from the middle of the tree along with the placement of the tree itself with its shadow have made the composition distinguished. Best regards.

Absolutely beautiful black and white landscape. Your title relates very well to a dying tree in an arid soil. The very dramatic clouds compliment the scene very well and affords nice balance. Congratulations, Hamid. - Lester

Best regards Hamid!

PDE

Excellent B&W work, Hamid ... nice compostion. Best regards

great work, excellent exposure and bw

Bob, thank you for your positive input. Much appreciated.

Alf, i should express my deep gratitude and appreciation for your thorough analysis and exact explanation. Also completely agreed with your wise suggestion, but any vertical framing would limit any opportunity to play with elements to be framed, especially space occupying ones like horizontal shadows. Anyway, that would very nice addition to the shot, but i preferred this composition for less elements and clean overall appearance in coordinance with the vastness and loneliness. Thank you so much for your time and positive input.

Anabela, Greatly appreciated for your continued encouragements and nice words. Highly valuable for me.

Fernando, I'm so happy you liked and accepted photo, and so much thanks for your suggestion. Actually when you return from any photo trek and review your shots, you realise that how many oppotunities existed that you actually lost them, and there is no chance to go back and correct them. This case may be such one, and for repeat shot, i must drive near 2500 km. But SO MANY POINTS I LEARNED FROM THIS SUGGESTIONS, AND USE THEM IN FUTURE SHOTS. Thank you again, dear friend.

Kallol, Highly appreciated and so much thanks for your nice warm words, continuous support and positive input.  

Ruud, Thank you for your time and opinion. Very valuable for me.

Sumon, So happy to see your nice comment and hear from you. Thanks for your perfect analysis and happy you liked it. Thanks so much.

Lester, so much thanks for your continued support, positive feedback and encouragements. Much appreciated.

Pierre, very happy you liked it and accepted the shot. Very much appreciated. 

Ricardo, thanks and gratitude for your time and positive feedback. Much appreciated.

Niki, I always am happy to see your warm words and positive input. So much appreciated.

My best regards,

Hamid.

Well chosen title for this strong image Hamed. Excellent contrast and grey tones.  Composition is also very good. 7

Hamid, this is outstanding. The thumbnail grabbed my attention.  Beautiful composition, the sad little trees against the amazing sky is a powerful statement.

I like how you composed this and realized.Simple elements very well seen,clouds that give dimension in vertical line,the dried trees,proportion with horizon line.Excellent grey tones,nd4 effect is well seen too.Compliments for this photo.

RC

This is a wonderful scenery.Your art makes it very wonderful and eye-catching.The b&w tones are nice and your view and camera angle are excellent,also!Wonderful composition.Thnx for taking it and sharing the beautiful scenes of our country!Best regards(Bobby).

Superb shot , wonderful B/W tons and details , good composition .................... Best regards.

Sincere thanks, JOHN, for your nice comment and positive feedback, and also for generous rate. Much appreciated.

Linda, Thank you for stopping by and this nice description. I'm so happy tou liked it. Highly appreciated.

Radu, Extremely thankful for your nice comment, warm words, and positive input. Greatly appreciated.

Bobby, Sincere thanks for your continuous support, encouragements, and nice warm words. Highly appreciated. Hozore hamvatane honarmandi mesle shoma barayam binahayat arzeshmand ast. Besiar mamnoonam.

Falak, So much thanks for your time, comment and positive feedback. Much appreciated.

My best regards,

Hamid.

Excellent POV and composition !!

The 3D effect  has been brought out very well.

Best regards,

TSR

I think Alf covered most of the most important technical aspects of this shot. I find it to be very interesting, especially your choice of POV, wonderful detail and perspective. The impressive sky certainly adds 'drama' to the shot. Well done Hamid!!

Most sincerely, Gail

I just noticed from the thumb nail in the critque request forum this image, its as if the clouds are now the leaves of the trees, very interesting and nice B&W

Just great. So simple and beautifull. Makes you think.

Regards. Cosmin

Unique and interesting work. Right choice as B&W style.