Firenze

I like it's square and his face expression. I do not like that focus is not on his face, but on his bottles... actually, not much focus at all, except upper left corner. face light is rather flat (but mach better than direct flash would be). his dark clothes are somewhat undertextured (well, that may be my monitor).

This is a good environmental portrait, but I agree that your autofocus somehow got fooled. Tone and expression are quite good, though.