Photography is about creating images with light. For indoor, night, fill light, or certain special effects, using electronic flashes to generate light becomes an important component in modern photography. Nikon’s current flash technology is called i-TTL, and they offer five different external flash options. So far all of those i-TTL flashes have three-digit model numbers in the form of SB-n00 (e.g. SB-600, SB-900 and there is also an SB-R200) while the older, non-i-TTL flashes have two-digit model numbers (e.g. SB-28 and SB-80 DX). Therefore, it is very easy to determine which ones are i-TTL compatible. This article provides a brief history of the evolution of Nikon TTL flash technology and a guide to those five i-TTL flashes.
The intro image demonstrates the size differences amongst the SB-900, SB-800 and SB-600.
Nikon introduced the TTL (through-the-lens) flash technology to its film SLRs (Single-Lens Reflex Cameras) in the mid 1980’s. The major advantage of TTL flash is that flash exposure is measured during the actual exposure, as the amount of light reflected off the film is detected by sensors placed inside the mirror box. When a sufficient amount of light is detected, the flash is electronically shut off instantaneously.
In 1999, Nikon released its first digital SLR, the D1. The new problem then was that the digital sensor and the anti-aliasing filter in front of it did not reflect light the same way traditional film does. As a result, Nikon had to modify its TTL flash technology as it was no longer possible to measure the amount of reflected light during the actual exposure. Instead, Nikon used pre-flashes and measured their strength to determine how much flash power was needed.
The initial technology was called D-TTL. It is merely a slight modification from film TTL. Instead of measuring the light reflected off the film during actual exposure, D-TTL carries out a quick series of pre-flashes after the mirror has flipped up but before the shutter opens. On D-TTL DSLR bodies, the outward-facing side of the shutter blades is painted light gray to reflect more light so that it would be easier to measure the pre-flash. Flash metering is still carried out by sensors placed inside the mirror box as before.
Correspondingly, Nikon also made a slight modification to its last film flash, the SB-28, into the SB-28 DX. All three D-TTL flashes Nikon would eventually introduce all have the “DX” suffix. (Subsequently, there were also the SB-50 DX and SB-80 DX.)
The D-TTL era lasted four years and Nikon only introduced four DSLRs that use D-TTL exclusively: the D1 family: the D1, D1H and D1X and the subsequent D100 in 2002. However, the entire D2 family is also backwards compatible with D-TTL; in fact, they are the only cameras that are both D-TTL and i-TTL compatible.
In July 2003, Nikon announced the D2H, the first of what would be four cameras from the D2 family, along with a new SB-800 flash. They were the first installment to Nikon’s iTTL and Creative Lighting System (CLS). The new triple-digit model number without the DX suffix indicated the new flash technology. The pre-flash is still required for digital, but it takes place slightly earlier in the exposure cycle, before the mirror flips up. Therefore, pre-flash exposure is measured inside the viewfinder instead of inside the mirror box.
In addition to TTL flash, CLS is a complex system of master and remote wireless flashes. There can be up to a total of three groups (A, B and C) of wireless remote flashes that can be controlled independently with different exposure compensations. There are also four separate channels (1 to 4) so that multiple photographers will not interfere with one another in the same room.
The SB-800 is essentially the same flash as the SB-80 DX, which was the last D-TTL flash, with a different pre-flash and exposure measurement technology. In fact, the two look very similar. From the back side, other than the model number, they look identical.
As the very first in the i-TTL/CLS series, the SB-800 can either be a stand-alone flash, a CLS master that is mounted onto the camera and controls other remote flashes, or a CLS wireless remote slave. As either a CLS master or slave, the SB-800 can use all three groups and all four channels.
For four years since its 2004 introduction, the SB-800 was Nikon’s best flash that has a lot of advanced features:
The SB-800 has a unique 5th battery option. It comes with an add-on compartment that can hold one AA battery. You can replace the regular battery chamber door with that compartment so that the SB-800 can use 5 AA batteries simultaneously, thus getting a slightly faster recycle time. Additionally, the SB-800 has an external high-voltage power input to use an external power supply for even faster recycle time.
The FP (focal plane) sync feature allows flash photography at any shutter speed, including faster than the typical maximum sync speed at 1/250 second. Under the FP Sync mode, the SB-800 will fire a number of flashes to cover the entire frame as the focal plane shutter moves across the frame. However, flash power is greatly reduced.
The SB-800 also has the best compatibility going forward and backward. It can work with film TTL and D-TTL bodies.
A minor downside for the SB-800 is that it has a somewhat cryptic menu system. The key to remember is that you need to hold down the center multi-selection pad for two seconds and the menu on the back LCD will switch to a different mode for master/remote selection as well as several optional settings. One example of the somewhat problematic menu system is the lock feature: on the SB-800, if you hold down both the Select (SEL) button and the on/off button for two seconds, the flash will enter the lock mode with a lock icon appearing on the LCD. All of a sudden, the controls on the SB-800 “will not work” any more. You need to hold down those two same buttons for two seconds to unlock the flash. I have seen people entering the lock mode accidentally and got stuck.
While the SB-800 is still widely available at various camera stores at the present time (December, 2008), it is quite clear that the new SB-900 is its replacement so that the SB-800 will unlikely to stay in the market for too much longer.
The SB-900 was introduced in July 2008 along with the D700 DSLR. It has a similar amount of flash power and the same CLS master/slave capabilities as the SB-800, but the SB-900 has a much improved menu system as well as a lot of new options. In particular, the SB-900 has a huge zoom head that can focus its flash beam to the 200mm angle of view, thus making it an excellent choice for long telephoto work. As a result, the SB-900 is much bigger in size than its predecessor and can be a little unstable when it is mounted on top of a small DSLR.
Concerning features, the SB-900 retains essentially all capabilities the SB-800 has and then some:
However, Nikon has removed backward compatibilities with D-TTL and film TTL from the SB-900 as those old cameras are no longer popular any more.
The SB-900 also has the lock feature, but they have apparently learned from the SB-800 experience so that the SB-900 has clear markings on the back of the flash about which two buttons to press simultaneously to engage and disengage the lock. There are many of these little improvements that make the SB-900 much easier to use than its predecessor.
The SB-600 was Nikon’s second installment to its iTTL flashes and is the “prosumer” model. It has a zoom head so that the flash power can be adjusted according to the lens’ focal length for FX-format coverage. Similar to the SB-800, that head can be rotated around for 270 degrees and tilted upward for bounce flash in both the horizontal and vertical orientations. It also has a built-in diffuser to cover a wider angle. However, unlike the SB-800 and SB-900, the SB-600 does not have a built-in bounce card and does not come with an attachable diffuser dome.
The SB-600 uses four AA batteries and has a recycle time around 4 seconds. It has no built-in high-voltage input to accept Nikon external battery packs. However, there are third-party options.
While it cannot server as the CLS commander, the SB-600 can be a CLS wireless remote that can be assigned to any one of the three CLS groups as well as any one of the four channels. Unfortunately, its menu system is very cryptic. Frequently you need to hold down two buttons simultaneously for two seconds to change the flash into a different mode. I have a difficult time to remember those options, especially since I don’t use the SB-600 very often. Fortunately, Nikon has provided a quick reference guide.
Along with the SB-800, the SB-600 is one of two flashes that are backward compatible with Nikon D-TTL as well as film TTL. However, the SB-600 does not have any built-in light sensor for non-TTL auto flash exposure. In other words, it does not support the A mode.
The SB-400 was introduced as a consumer-grade flash for casual photographers. While it is iTTL compatible, it is not part of CLS as it can neither be a wireless master nor remote. The SB-400 comes in a convenient small package using only two AA batteries. It does not have a zoom head so that it cannot focus its output to match the focal length of the lens used. Its flash head can be rotated upward for bounce flash in the horizontal orientation (landscape) but not vertically.
We are not going to cover the SB-400 in any great detail. It is a flash that is more affordable and is quite popular among casual photographers who would like something a little better and stronger than the pop-up flash on most DSLRs. If you are a more advanced photographer, I would suggest at least an SB-600.
The SB-R200 is a specialized flash for advanced CLS. It is not a shoe-mount flash so that it can only be a remote flash in a CLS setting. (There is also a wired option for old film SLRs.) Typically it is used on a little stand or mounted onto a ring that is attached to a lens as part of a macro flash system.
There are essentially three different ways to have a commander to control a Nikon CLS set up:
Use a flash that is capable to be a commander, namely either the SB-800 or SB-900. They can control all three flash groups A, B, and C and work with any one from channels 1 to 4.
Use the pop-up flash on a DSLR body that has this capability, e.g. the D80, D90, D200, D300, and D700. Those pop-up flash can control group A and B but not C. (The D70 and D70s’ pop-up flash can also be the commander but in a more limited manner.)
Use the dedicated commander unit the SB-800, which can also control all three groups and use any one of the four channels.
The SU-800 is a stand-alone unit. If you have a DSLR body that does not have a pop-up flash (e.g. the D2 and D3 families) or a pop-up flash that does not have the CLS master capability (e.g. D40, D40x and D60) and you would rather not have a big flash sitting on the hot shoe as the master controller, the SU-800 is a good alternative.
Nikon groups two SB-R200 remote flashes with a lot of accessories such as little flash stands, diffusers, gel filters, etc. into an R1 Wireless Close-up Speedlight System. If one owns a capable DSLR, they can simply use the camera’s pop-up flash to control the remotes. Otherwise, there is the R1C1 set which is the R1 set plus an SU-800 controller. Both the R1 kit and the R1C1 kit come in a nice carrying box.
For photographers who would like to use their flashes on a flash bracket, it is convenient to use a flash “extension cord” such as the SB-28 and SB-29 to connect the flash’s hot shoe to the camera’s hot shoe.
The SC-28 is functionally identical to the previous SC-17 extension cord, except that it is black in color and uses the new style twist lock to attach onto a hot shoe. The SC-29 has an additional LED AF-assist light on the module that mounts onto the camera’s hot shoe such that it can replace the AF-assist light on the flash. This extra feature on the SC-29 only works with flashes that have the additional electronic contacts on the front of their hot shoe, namely the SB-600, SB-800 and SB-900.
For news, wedding and event photographers, frequently it is very important to have extremely fast flash recycle time as the photographer needs to capture multiple flash images in quick succession as the event unfolds. The typical 4 to 5-second recycle time after a full-capacity flash on the SB-800 and SB-900 is not nearly fast enough. One option is to use external lead-acid batteries, but Nikon provides compact power pack alternatives. The SB-8A accepts 6 AA batteries while the new SD-9 uses 8. They can be connected to the front high-voltage input to the SB-800 and SB-900 and provide recycle times around 1 to 1.5 seconds after a full blast.
|Guide Number at ISO 200||157.5 (feet)||174||138||98|
|Weight (w/out batteries)||15.1oz, 427g||12.4oz, 350g||10.8oz, 306g||4.5oz, 128g|
|Battery Type||4 AA||4 AA, 5 AA||4 AA||2 AA|
|Recycle Time with NiMH AA Batteries||2.3 sec||4 sec, 2.9 sec with 5 AA||2.5 sec||2.5 sec|
|Swivel Head for Bounce Flash||yes||yes||yes||horizontal only|
|fixed at 27mm FX
|Flip-out Diffuser Coverage||17mm FX
|Add-on Diffuser Dome Coverage||17mm FX
|14mm||not supplied||not supplied|
(non-TTL auto flash)
For those who own current Nikon DSLRs (as well as the F6 film SLR), i-TTL and CLS is simply a wonderful flash system that can be as simple as just the built-in pop-up flash, one external flash, or it could be a complex, multi-flash system that works in a coordinated manner.
If you are a more casual digital photographer taking the typical family and travel images and would like something a bit stronger than the camera’s built-in flash, the SB-400 would be a good, affordable choice without any advanced features.
For the more intermediate to advanced photographers, the SB-600 is still quite affordable but is packed with useful features such as horizontal and vertical bounce flash as well as serving as a wireless remote.
For serious amateurs to professional photographers, especially those who are into wedding, wildlife, news, and certain types of sports photography, the SB-800 and SB-900 should be the best tools because of their power and fast recycle times. Additionally, for a lot of indoor, controlled settings, multiple Nikon CLS flashes can work together to produce beautiful results. At this point the SB-900 is certainly state of the art, but some may find its large size to be somewhat inconvenient.
Shortly after I had written this article, I bought a copy of Nikon School’s new DVD: A Hands-on Guide to Creative Lighting, featuring professional photographers Bob Krist and Joe McNally. I watched the entire DVD immediately and then repeated some selected sections. The DVD is a bit pricy but provides an excellent presentation on the entire Creative Lighting System. The DVD has two main sections. First Bob Krist reviews the basics about the quality of light and then builds a three-flash set up for a typical portrait session, one flash at a time. He also describes how to operate the SB-900, 800, 600, and R200.
The second part of the DVD features Joe McNally with Bob Krist assisting him at three locations: (1) the Boston Ballet photographing several dancers in both action and group portrait settings, (2) a bridal portrait session at a country inn, and (3) a fisherman portrait set up in a New England harbor where McNally eventually uses a total of a dozen i-TTL flashes working in coordination. They demonstrated many different CLS setups under many different real-life settings.
If you would like to learn more about lighting with Nikon i-TTL flashes and how the system works together in actual settings, this DVD is a really good way to go.
Photo.net’s partners have the following flashes and accessories available. Even better, your purchase helps to support photo.net.