Radiant tree

I would really appreciate any comments and critiques. I realize that I

have chopped a little bit of the tree on the sides. I guess I need a

wide angle attachment in the new year. :)

Nice fat tree.

Very simplistic beauty . Nice composure and contrast,6/5

Simple and elegant, I like how the tree fills the frame, but there's enough space around it that we can still see its surroundings.

Gary and Miguel for your comments.

Mandar,

 

Well composed shot. I think that you succeeded where Ansel Adams tried... the trees in the background lend an eerie edge, and actually contribute to the shape of the main subject. The frame is good, too. This is one that wouldn't look quite right matted white. The only thing I can find to complain about is that the foreground is a little heavy on the left side. By the way, do you live in Boston?

 

Andrew

Andrew, Thanks for your comment. I like the points you mention. The slope from left to right does make it asymmetric and may give a feeling of a strong tilt. I would like to redo this photograph. Yes, I was indeed living in the Boston area for some time, I have moved since the begining of this year.