Ocean Cove near Whitehouse Creek

The falloff in brightness at the corners suggests vignetting/use of wrong lens and/or tele-extendeer--oh, you used grandma's Brownie. Well, it's a photo and you wanted it rated. You should crop differently. Otherwise the photo is very nice, although it appears a blue filter (or perhaps old film?) may have resulted in overly blue scene. The wave action and the composition are nice. Not rated because of the technical problem noted until it's submitted cropped.

What can I say, I used a Brownie made in 1906 to take the photo. Someday, I'll photoshop the corners, but for the time being, I'm O.K. with it given how it was taken.

I finally got around to replacing the original image. Look, no vignetting. That's what the critique system is all about, holding us all to a higher standard.