maria conversano 0 Posted September 14, 2004 Me too, Tim. I love the good photographers that i can meet on this site and grat photograpy that i can see on this pages. But..... I agree with you, Tim, for the morst part, and i whant to believe in the honesty of people. But... Link to comment
francescomartini 0 Posted September 14, 2004 No!!! Look well..Your wrong!! Your "person" have give to Guido 7/7..... Link to comment
raywei 0 Posted September 14, 2004 7/7 by me. Great capture of a foggy scene. Congrats. Link to comment
Guest Guest Posted September 14, 2004 My 'person' gave 1/1 but in this moment she has not 1/1, she had 43 1/1 but now all her ratings has changed. Well, no problem, better for PN, we need fair play. Link to comment
behel 0 Posted September 14, 2004 i can hardly believe this "person" rated low purposedly. she is a great photographer and a very nice person, as far as i know. it is true that since jean told us about her, all my 1/1 ratings have disappeared too. but, previous to this "1/1 affair," this person had rated me high on other photos. so, i guess either it's a bug, either it was an error she made when giving ratings. anyway, again, i can't believe she did that on purpose, and i'll keep on browsing her very nice portfolio. only my two cents. thanks. Link to comment
Guest Guest Posted September 14, 2004 Nice mood but I found it a bit busy on the dock (probably because of the handling and the lamp....) Link to comment
chips2 0 Posted September 15, 2004 Beautiful ....impressive composition ...Well done Like it very much... Link to comment
guido_fulgenzi 0 Posted September 15, 2004 I totally agree with you about Sarah talent,I've been also high rated here once in a while and I confirm she is such a good photographer,that's why I said i was absolutely surprised about what they have reported to me and what "at the beginning" I could realized,first of all I got to say that everybody has the own taste and so people could not appreciate my image and they have all the reason to give me low rating,but you know that in this case 1/1 makes me think that there are hidden reasons.In the meantime the famous 1/1 disappeard,I start thinking that was due,like you said,to a computer bug!Best Regards.Guido Link to comment
loredana facchinetti 0 Posted September 15, 2004 Hei, che incanto questa foto! Poesia ed immagine! Link to comment
roberta_bagnacani 0 Posted September 15, 2004 Lavoro eccellente, un'atmosfera unica! :) Link to comment
henrimanguy 0 Posted September 17, 2004 Excellent composition with a great effect of fog. I will probably go to Venice this autumn and I hope have the same fog. A little sun also, and not too much rain. You can see my last loaded photos here : Rocks and sand ; The town of Is ; Evening, Trevignon beach Link to comment
mike werkhoven 0 Posted September 18, 2004 A true "Guido", Venice misty lonely and poetic. Link to comment
moniamura 0 Posted September 23, 2004 che strana atmosfera si respira in questa foto.. complimenti, 蠭olto bella! Link to comment
carsten_ranke 0 Posted September 25, 2004 You are an artist - another excellent one from you. Moody, dreamy, perfect colors and composition. I would not crop at the left side, but I would try to clone out the lamp pole (?) on the right. Regards, Carsten Link to comment
romeyer.jp 0 Posted October 12, 2004 I come late on this picture, that certainly deserves a comment, and opens a debate on rating... Obviously, your shot is a very nice one Guido, and rating "3/3...below average"...without any comment is as ridiculous as 1/1...I am new here, and have already "suffered" of same attitude and been confused by rating in all directions ! anyway, there is nothing to win here, isn't it, except friendship (I hope...but I may be a "dreamer") and some exchanges, experiences... Then I come to my rating and I explain, otherwise there is no exchange, no learning from each other...and finaly "complimenti" but no further improvements, no? Then I think your shot deserves 7 in originality, because not so often we see such result in fog conditions ! Aesthetically speaking, the whole results is absolutely beautiful to look at...IMHO it may be even better, and I fully share the 1st comment of Pnina : crop a little too wide on the left (shadows on top left distract the viewer), and a little too wide on the bottom : consequently the main subject is too much centered and loose power (IMHO)...for this I rate 5...not to say that your picture compared to others rated 7/7 do not deserve as much...certainly it does...just to say that your work is great, but can even be better, outstanding... Sorry Guido, I jump on your picture as an example, I think the same for a lot, starting mine's (!!!)...and considering the number of ratings already accumulated on your beautiful image, my 5/7 will change nothing...it will all the more change nothing because I will not register this rating ! so for now, this is a comment only... If you disagree this approach and analysis, please, tell it to me...because for me It was in a positive mood - and keep on the good work! friendly Link to comment
guido_fulgenzi 0 Posted October 12, 2004 I wish every pn members would be like you,your's is a deep analisys and I certanly respect your opinion,because is a costructive criticism.You are right about the central subject but I couldn't move from that spot otherwise I would've been in the water.For the other point I understand what you mean but I left the trees as they were to accentuate the sensation of fog.Regards.Guido Link to comment
an.deceuninck 0 Posted October 29, 2006 love your photo, real Hitchcock-photo, but then a warm one! it makes one very curious what's behind the fence. Regards An Link to comment
Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now