Sundown in the Majes desert

Majes desert in southern Peru. This is red-spectrum extended BW film

version of the color photograph you can compare on:

http://www.photo.net/photodb/photo?photo_id=2412395

I would like to know which version (BW/Color) is more appropiate in

your opinion. Thanks for looking and any comments are welcome.

I think that maybe there is too much foreground which distracts me from the dramatic subject.

Miroslave, this photo has a perfect composition with the diagonal lines.. I lived 3 years in Hindukush mountains and the vista here reminds me of the views of the high mountains of my youth. Very well done. jana

Such a dramatic landscape -- almost like a seascape in fact. To me, the extreme contrast of the foreground overpowers the mountains in the distance. So I kind of agree with Marvin's comment above, except that for me it is not that there is too much foreground, but just a distracting foreground.