Tammy

Something about that leg doesn't look right. The lighting on the face is perfect. I like it a lot with the leg cropped out. Very nice pose, lighting and expression.

I find her leg rather disturbing in that position.

i like the leg because it makes the angle of her body a little less typical-fashion-photo-y (?). but maybe a little more curvature in the back or twist in the neck is really needed to achieve the slightly uncomfortable, curled-in, almost self-protective look that sets off that face (wow, what a face to work with!). i love your work and look forward to seeing more.

Really nice crop. In camera?

I love this shot, except for the leg, I'd personally crop a tiny bit above the knee-cap. With that cropping, I'd give it an Aesthetics rating of 8, possibly 9.

A great shot.