Painting the sky

Thank you for critique and/or rate.

Bravo!...e forza Roma!

Sento l'odore dell'aria e la voce del fievole vento...bravo Andrea.Michele

Gorgeous! Viva Roma! Did you edit it, or did it really look this way?

Beautiful image.

Bellissimo cielo e bella luce!!

Questa l'ho già vista...DigitalCameraMagazine ti dice qualcosa?? Un saluto e complimenti dal Marielpiskel del forum!!

Ciao.

Beautiful

When you edit - edit well. I gave you a 1 for aesthetics - not because it was edited - but because you did a bad job editing. When you edit the picture should be perfect because you have everything in your control - there is no excuse for leaving bad edges. 4 for originality - again that suffers because you had everything under your control and you came out with a picture that to a trained eye looks bad. Next time spend more time editing - this picture has potential, just refine it!

Many thanks to all for your comment, I really appreciated it.

 

Nathan: Thank you, the different point of view are always positive, no problem about 1 for aesthetics (it's your opinion) and I don't do photo to receive rate, I do photo for my enjoy.

Rate it's only a way to understand if what I do is pleasant not only for me but also for some other people.

 

What I don't undersdand in your comment is why 1? My work is so terrible? Is not perfect (I'm sure about this point) but I don't think "very bad" (the meaning of 1). Just for your information this photo was made by 2 different shot, in this "composition" a only insered a real sky (captured in Italy) to my 1st San Peter shot. Please fell free to reply even including some particolar about the wrong "edge" (maybe I can lear somethink....). Enjoy your time and of course sorry for my bad english!

 

A beauty!

Much better than a postcard! Gorgeous shot ... it puts me right THERE! Thanks!

Hi there, sure - let me try to help explain. I uploaded the parts that need work. The reason I went so low was because all this would take to correct is a little time and effort - always try to take the time in editing to make things look right.

 

Second besides the bad edges, because there is water in the picture it becomes apparent (at first glance) that the picture is edited because the sky isn't reflecting. This is a more complex issue, that again takes some time to fix. Also, the shadows on the buildings are not right (to my viewing). If I am correct the sun is shining from the right side - but highlight on all the buildings is on the left - so that doesn't work. Hope this helps some! :0)

Ciao Andrea, ti ritengo un bravissimo fotografo, con un bell'occhio e un ottima tecnica... a mio parere (personalissimo) non hai bisogno di montare due scatti per ottenere una bella foto, i tuoi lavori migliori sono proprio quelli non montati!!!

Thank you for your suggestion, I really appreciated it, I will try!

 

Grazie mille per i complimenti, troppo buono! :-)

Nathan , I also see bad edges but i not agree with your rate.I know why you estimated so, and this knows every different except you .

 

 

Truly a beautiful piece of photography.

Modern yet classical Roma. Timeless!

wow, amazing colors and lighting. san pietro looks like a ghost in the background - i like it! great job.

Super shot, with brillant lighting. Congratulations.

Very god portfolio Andrea, I like all your pictures.Nice lights,colors and composition.

"Sorry for my English". Saludos desde Espa�a

A very evocative picture of the Eternal City. Bravo. (7/6)