walk at a polish beach in winter

I am grateful for any comments !

Scratches and dust on the scanned image need to be cleaned up and the center section is too bright where the dog is looking. the composition is good. Sort of a cold and lonesome feeling being portrayed.

Strong moody atmosphere, I like the tone but the trees are a bit to outlined. I also have the feeling there is to much (photo) to the left. Or the person should stand a little more to the left.

I really like this mood also-you looking at the girl (?), looking at the dog who's watching something down the beach. There's an interesting symmetry to the picture. Fascinating to look at. I would like to have seen a little more foreground perhaps (so that we could see her shadow). Very nice, thanks for sharing.

I am very glad that you gave me comments to this photo. For explaining. I wanted this cold mood, the scratches and the hard lines should make the look of the photo even colder. A girl lonely.

Thx again ! More comments are welcome