Joe Camel

converted to bw

Excellent composition!

Good strong image. O could do without the Samsung and Chevrolet logos in the background... they distract.

I love this.

Camel....Only problem I see here is that stale posed look where the subject is always staring off into space after being told to so by the photographer.

Nice composition. Very graphic. I have to put aside my anti-smoking stance, and say that it is a well done image. The only thing that bothers me is the mark on his forehead. I would have removed that as it draws too much attention of the eye. Reminds me of when bankrobbers paint a red dot on their nose to keep people from remembering their faces.

Nice B&W from a D60. I like the image; the composition of the sbject and exposure are good, but the background is cluttered and distracts from the image IMHO.

Nice dynamic image, At first I didnt like the two advertisements but now find they help put the image in prospective

Colossal .. really like this. Looks like a helluva lot of post production went in to this to get the final result. The apparent oversharpening effect really adds to it .. gives it that grainy and gritty look that makes it for me. My only criticism is the highlight blowout on the bridge of the nose.

 

Excellent work !!

 

zzzz..

Wow, this is so good. Well done.

I don't know... This doesn't work for me. I find the background confusing, and I'm not really sure what the point of the photo is. Also, the guy really looks like he's never smoked a cigarette in his life. On top of the fact that the cigarette hasn't been lit, it's kind of hanging a little too loosely from his unclosed lips-just like I'd imagine a little kid might hold one if he was trying to imitate his dad or a movie star. Of course, I know very little about advertising and even less about smoking, but I'm just not convinced by this image.

super