Untitled

Don't comment unless you have a well calibrated monitor!

I'm trying out a new workflow:

scanned provia to raw file

raw processed in raw therapee

final tweaks in photoshop

Raw therapee seems to give me better colors than PS. Curious what you

think.

I am going to say that I have a well calibrated eye, overlooking your thoughts about my monitor, here let me give you a little old school basics, I look at my camera screen and then compare my monitor, all monitor calibration mean squat if it does not match my cameras output, with that said, this image has a red overcast, like you may have used a magenta filter in your post process.

I don't like when people tell me not to do something on a public forum, who are you?

Im a photography school trained color printer.  Spent endless hours in a color darkroom.

Unless you have calibrated your monitor using proper hardware there is no way to see the colors accurately.  Sorry. That's just a fact.

when you have a background in printing, sites like this can be very frustrating because you have no idea what the viewer is actually seeing.

thank you for the clarification, I did not know you were looking for technical feedback and not what professional photographers might see with their eyes. I am just a photographer since 1975.

All I have in my defense is when I do a wedding and get prints back, I can lay the prints on the wedding gown and they match, I think it best that I skipped all the techno gamma color stuff, I would have thought something was off when it really was not.

Humor me and take a paint chip off that wall and put it next to your monitor.