It might sound simple yet one of those images which are so delicate to achieve and requires great skill and talent, well, you did it all in a superb manner and your exposure most of all, playing a major rule in with quality of this image.

The place where this big tree been placed n side the frame work is another right choice and do give a 3D effect to this lovely image appearance while the contrast and tone again add here to have such fine and well balanced composition.

Remarkable work been made here, thank you for sharing it and wishing you all of the best my friend.

Dear Rashed,

I`m in joy and pleasure with your warm words and enthusiastic comment!I`m glad that see you won a golden critiquer,also.

Take care of your self.

Regards(Bobby).

One of your best to me. Simple and excellent composition in B/W. Lovely title too. All the best. Regards.

Hi dear Kaushik,

This is kind of you and thnx alot for your appreciation and warm visit!

Regards(Bobby).

Nice choice of b/w in this image - good eye.

Hi dear Dale,

Thnx alot for your comment and kind words!

Regards(Bobby).

Great shot and great title! Warm regards, Ilkka

Hieno dear Ilkka,

Thnx so much for your warm visit and comment!Miss you and Anne so much!

Regards(Bobby).

Superb composition ..............Best Regards

Hi dear Kawan,

Thnx alot for your time and comment,my friend!

Regards(Bobby).

this photo reminds me of someone running.... as if they were running towards the tree. its a freeing photo,, pure and basic,,,bobbiie

Dear Bobbiie and dear My,

Thnx so much for your kind words and comments!

Regards(Bobby).

Wonderful shot, Bobby...very nice shadow of the tree and it is well balanced by the original tree itself...beautiful tonality...my best

Love that one: the tree and the shodow comes great. BR Joerg

Thnx alot dear friends for your time,comments and visits!

Regards(Bobby).

Bobby, extremely sorry for being late to the party, due to unavoidable circumstance. I like the cropping, tonal quality and caption.In a barren land, the presence of this tree and its shadow are a boon.

Hi dear Amalda,

It`s not late!Welcome to this shot and thnx alot for your time and enthusiastic words!

Regards(Bobby).

hi bobby, i read this interesting discussion, and i agree that the photocan become better, also if is important not to loose the simplicity of the scene, that is the particularity of the photo. maybe the wter is the critic point, becouse only here this softness doesnt exist. i tried to change something, if you permit, becouse wity my english is better an example (also if done on 40 kb...) that an explication. ciao!

Hi dear Andrea,

Thnx that you followed the discussion.Thnx alot and take care!

Regards(Bobby).

A photograph with eye-catching bw tonality. A composition with wonderful light-and-shadow management. ... 7 ... Best regards.

Hi dear Sumonda,

Thnx alot for your warm comment and kind visit!

Take care and thnx for your generous rating.

Regards(Bobby).

Hi Bobby, this is a very nice, i.e., creative and aesthetic compo IMO, and the b&w editing is also very good / adds a very important element. I like the pretty sharp / bright contrasts of shapes and textures, which are highlighted by the special editing and lights and shades (as if they had been captured using an Ilford 800 ISO film which was designed to enable / take shots in pretty low light in former years and was applied here in bright light... ;-)). 6-7. BR / Volker

Thnx alot dear Volker for your warm comment and visit!

Regards(Bobby).

So at last I am back on the PN again after a long break. It was so good to hear from you my friend when I was absent.

This is a very beautiful creation from you. I like the way you have composed and exposed the image, and the shadowplay adds to the total effect. The B/W conversion works very well and it is a real pleasure to view this image over and over again. Great work from you Bobby.

Take good care my friend and all the best to you and your family

Jannica

Hi dear Jannica,

I missed you so much and welcome back after a long period!

I`m glad that you like it and thnx alot for your comment!

Best regards(Bobby).