Sea Stars

Photographer's Request for Critique

--Pierre Dumas

Sea Stars

Thank you for your kind attention dear colleagues! PDE

Critiques

Richard Cox , March 26, 2008; 07:46 P.M.

Very artsy. I like it.

Pierre Dumas [Frequent poster] , March 26, 2008; 07:55 P.M. (edit | delete)

Welcome Richard!

Welcome to my portfolio and to PN and thank you for your kind comment!

PDE

Tina Karina [subscriber] , March 26, 2008; 09:19 P.M.

Very beautiful sea stars and also very interesting composion. Simple the best. Pierre, thank for your comments and ratings one of my photo. Tina

Paula Grenside [subscriber] , March 27, 2008; 11:23 A.M.

fantastic details in these seastars, Pierre. Can almost touch the texture.

Goran Anastasovski , March 27, 2008; 04:19 P.M.

Odlicno. Bez komentar.

Vicente Concha [subscriber] [Frequent poster] , March 27, 2008; 07:27 P.M.

Hola Pierre .

Excellent visual impact, great composition. Sensational texture. Congratulations. Best wishes. Vicente.

Joan Newhall [Frequent poster] , March 27, 2008; 07:41 P.M.

Beautiful. This is my kind of photo.....Thank you for visiting my portfolio and leaving your comments. I really appreciate it.

Cynthia Jean [subscriber] , March 27, 2008; 09:55 P.M.

Pierre

Starry night! Very sharp and very nice composition. Take care

Dave Hollander [subscriber] [Frequent poster] , March 27, 2008; 10:00 P.M.

Lovely, Pierre!

Joseph Tury [subscriber] , March 27, 2008; 10:49 P.M.

PDE

Super detail my friend!

Bruce Lee [subscriber] , March 28, 2008; 06:35 A.M.

Very simple and very beautiful!

Gorm Rudschinat [subscriber] , March 28, 2008; 09:49 A.M.

great stars, like kom. and colours, thanks for comments on my pictures :)Gorm

Stefano Anghileri , March 28, 2008; 11:18 A.M.

Indeed beautiful composition. Compliments

Saso Naumovski , March 28, 2008; 02:13 P.M.

zdravo

super slika me bendisa!!

Costas Ellos , March 28, 2008; 03:32 P.M.

I like it Petraki !!

Richard Gale , March 28, 2008; 07:13 P.M.

wonderful image very well composed, Rich.

Brian Larson [subscriber] , March 28, 2008; 10:18 P.M.

Very nice details, congradulations. Would you like to visit a bird called an American Woodcock.

Joseph Popper [subscriber] , March 29, 2008; 07:24 P.M.

Beautifully made, Pierre. Warm regards...

Michael Meneklis [subscriber] [Frequent poster] , March 30, 2008; 09:08 A.M.

Very fine macro and composition.

Torfinn Johannessen , March 30, 2008; 03:36 P.M.

WonderfuL, just wonderful... Excellent macro Pierre.

Christal Steele [subscriber] [Frequent poster] , March 31, 2008; 03:35 P.M.

Pierre

Very elegant in its simplicity. I love it, and I love the slight texture to your background which plays nicely with the texture of the starfish. Bravo!

Renny McGovern [subscriber] , April 01, 2008; 12:21 A.M.

Pierre,

...I really like this.... a graceful design with an understated and lasting beauty... and thanks for your comments! I shall be back...

Louis Blair [subscriber] [Frequent poster] , April 02, 2008; 09:07 P.M.

Just plain magnificent.8/8...Bravo

Rakesh Syal [Current POW Recipient] , April 04, 2008; 04:16 P.M.

7/7 All the way!!

One of your best, PD!!

Best regards, Rakesh!

Satheesh Nair [subscriber] , April 06, 2008; 11:42 P.M.

Excellent shot PDE!!!

Goran Kalanj , July 21, 2008; 06:32 P.M.

Beautiful !

Awny Betts , August 18, 2008; 11:43 A.M.

Beautiful!

This is amazing! What great detail! Excellent work, as usual!

Dikki Hurst , August 25, 2008; 10:28 A.M.

wow

Love it simply but massive impact. it jumps out of the page and demands your attention

Dikki

Sandra Blake [subscriber] , February 14, 2009; 01:31 P.M.

Pierre-

I have just found this in your portfolio and love it. Black and creamy white create the perfect contrast to show off the intricacy of the sea star underside (and I love the fact that you called them by the correct, name, sea star, not star fish). This is clean, contemporary "natural" art - often times beauty is best exhibited as the essence of simplicity. Nothing more to say about this - it's gorgeous and well done. I think it's unfortunate that some viewers seem to have a "knee-jerk" dislike to anything in black and white or dark and neutrals and immediately assign a low rating. I've experienced that on a couple of my photos and have seen the same on other's works. I guess art works like music when it comes to mass appeal - "Fast and loud, please the crowd; sweet and low, watch them go." Oh, yes 7/7 on this one (7 = excellence, not perfection. I think sometimes we end to forget that).

Cheers and congrats on another one well done!

Pierre Dumas [Frequent poster] , February 14, 2009; 04:08 P.M. (edit | delete)

Thank you Sandra!

I only don't know why have I marked this picture as montage?! If it is montage it is only the picture put on the black background after selecting! I know I had one big and two smaller and they are obviously different, therefore I didn't have to be a montage!

PDE

I like this compo very much and the sharpness you've achieved.

both items make this a high quality photograph.

rgds

Good photo!!!

Best regards my friend

A definite eye catcher ! ! Mesmerising !

I love the simplicity and graphic intensity of this shot.

Excellent very good detail, congrats //Salvador 

What an amazing shot! Technically and esthetically superb. Well done! Best regards, Alain

Well done, I like it very much.

very nice shot ......

Just love this shot...

All the best from Bangkok

Jeff

great sharpness!

Excellent composition, light, sharpness... I could definitely hang this on my wall ! "Simple" yet very effective.

excellent, sharp picture!

I have a new series for you in the account I used to leave this comment. They're on the front page. best, jamie

Love the composition and symmetry. It also does not hurt that it is beautiful!