Incandescent BW

I decided to try a BW conversion on one of my favorite shots from my

West Coast trip., what do you think?

Younes, I like how you have drawn the symmetry of those two submerged rocks with the peaks. I find the b/w version slightly dark though. It would be interesting to see the color version too.

great,I like the atmophere here you make!

Thanks for your input guys. Lalit, here is the color version

I liked the color version of this image (you had posted this ealier, as I recall?); and normally I'm a huge black and white aficianado, but I think Lalit is right, this is 'dark.' Just a suggestion, but what about a change from the vertical format to a square format, and crop the bottom up to just above the two large dark rocks? Keep tinkering, Amigo; there's a black and white image in there. Cheers! Chris

oh..man! I am glad I asked for color version. it is amazing!

Thanks for your input guys...I've reworked it a bit, what do you think?

Very nice b&w image, Younes! I like it!

Younes,guess we all see things differently, your first one is my choice, to me it creates a sense of mystery.A small portion of the mountain reveals itself, but the rest is hidden & unknown.The second one being slightly lighter does not create the same response. Best Regards-Ross